Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Farm-Level Revenue Sensitivity Analysis

Ask what happens to the farm if milk drops two dollars, and most people answer with a shrug or a worry. A sensitivity analysis replaces that with a number, which is the first step toward doing something about it.

The method in one sentence

Pick one result you care about, change one input at a time over a sensible range, and record what the result does. Then change two inputs together. That is the whole technique.

Build a three-by-three grid

Use your own figures. This example uses made-up round numbers: a 100-cow herd shipping 24,000 cwt a year at a $21.00 mailbox price, with feed costing $215,000.

Set milk price at $19, $21 and $23 per cwt. Set feed cost at 10 percent below base ($193,500), base ($215,000) and 10 percent above ($236,500). The result is income over feed cost for the year.

  • Price $19: $262,500 with low feed, $241,000 at base, $219,500 with high feed.
  • Price $21: $310,500 with low feed, $289,000 at base, $267,500 with high feed.
  • Price $23: $358,500 with low feed, $337,000 at base, $315,500 with high feed.

Now read the grid. Each $1.00 per cwt of price is worth $24,000 a year. A 10 percent feed swing is $21,500, about $0.90 per cwt. So a 10 percent feed rise nearly cancels a $1.00 price gain. Seeing that cost-to-price ratio in your own numbers is the real value. The income over feed cost guide explains the measure used here.

Extend the grid to full costs, and you can see which cells fall below your break-even price.

Add the levers you control

Price and feed are market-driven. Test the ones you influence.

  • Components. A 0.1 point rise in protein test on 2,400,000 pounds is 2,400 pounds of protein. At a made-up $2.00 per pound, that is $4,800, or $0.20 per cwt. Use real prices from the USDA AMS monthly announcement when you run your own.
  • Volume. Shipping 5 percent fewer cwt, or 1,200, cuts revenue by $25,200 at $21.00, but feed will also fall somewhat. Note how much of your feed is truly variable.
  • Deductions and premiums. A $0.10 per cwt change is $2,400 on 24,000 cwt.
  • Timing. Shift revenue and costs by a month to see the cash flow effect. The cash flow scenario planner is built for that.

Keep it honest

Sensitivity analysis is not a forecast. Do not label a column as what will happen. Label it as what would happen if. Use ranges you have actually seen in your own records, plus one worse case you hope never to see.

Watch for inputs that move together. Feed and milk prices are not independent; if you assume the worst feed and the worst price at once, you may be planning for a case that is less likely than either alone, and the reverse can happen too. Try pairs that make sense for your farm.

Check your base case against your milk statement. If the grid's base cell does not match last year's actual, fix the base first. The Penn State milk check guide shows how to compute the mailbox price that should go in it.

Turn the grid into a decision

Ask three questions of the finished grid.

  1. In which cells do we fall below cash break-even? How likely do those combinations seem?
  2. Which single input moves the answer most? That is where to spend management time.
  3. Would a risk tool change the worst cells? Read about FSA's Dairy Margin Coverage on its program page and talk with a licensed agent or lender about the rest.

Put the grid in the same folder as your budget and the revenue and volume dashboard, and update it when your base changes. It takes an hour and it stays useful for a year.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: Penn State Extension, Understanding Your Milk Check · FSA, Dairy Margin Coverage Program

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.