Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Benchmarking Your Dairy Against Others

Every dairy farmer has heard the neighbor's number: his cows average more, his feed bill is lower, his somatic cell count is a thing of beauty. Benchmarking is the disciplined version of that conversation, with definitions that match. Done properly it tells you where to spend your next hour of management. Done badly it sends you chasing a figure that was never comparable.

Pick a comparison group that fits

The first decision is who you are compared with. A 60-cow grazing herd and a 2,000-cow freestall dairy can both be profitable and still have little in common on a per-cow basis.

  • By size. USDA ERS publishes milk cost of production estimates that vary by state and by size of operation, downloadable as spreadsheets, so you can see costs for operations near your scale.
  • By type. FINBIN, run by the University of Minnesota Center for Farm Financial Management, describes itself as one of the largest sources of farm financial and production benchmarks. Its report types include dairy costs and returns by size of herd, and benchmark reports that compare your farm to a group of similar farms.
  • By region. Extension dairy programs, such as Cornell PRO-DAIRY, run dairy-specific business programming for their own states.

Ask what is in the group. Farm business management programs tend to enroll farms that already keep good records, so their averages can run better than the typical farm. That is not a flaw, only a fact to keep in mind.

Match the definitions before you match the numbers

Most bad benchmarking is a definitions problem. Before comparing cost per cwt, confirm each of these on both sides.

  1. Is unpaid family labor charged at a wage, or left out?
  2. Is a return on owned land and capital charged, or only cash interest paid?
  3. Is depreciation included, and how was it figured?
  4. Are heifers and cull cows valued the same way, and is cull cow and calf income netted out or counted as revenue?
  5. Is the figure per cwt of milk sold, or per cwt energy-corrected?

Our guide to labor, land and overhead in cost accounting covers the items beginners miss. If your costs omit family labor and the benchmark includes it, you will look better than you are.

Choose measures that point to action

A long list of ratios is easy to collect and hard to act on. A short set works better.

  • Cost of production per cwt and income over feed cost per cow or per cwt (see the income over feed cost guide).
  • Milk sold per cow per day.
  • Operating expense ratio, term debt coverage and working capital, the measures lenders look at.
  • Replacement costs. Penn State Extension says replacement animals typically account for 15 to 20 percent of milk production costs.

Penn State has also grouped farms into profit categories, such as the top 20 percent and the low 40 percent, to find where costs separate. That is the most useful way to read a benchmark. Ask not "am I average?" but "where do the most profitable farms differ from me?"

Read the gap, then check it

Say your feed cost per cwt is higher than the group's. Do not cut feed on the spot. Check three things first: is your milk per cow lower (spreading costs over fewer cwt), is your ration priced at market while others raise their own feed, and is your measurement the same? Penn State's heifer cost analysis noted that farms matching crop acres to animal numbers tended to buy less feed and be positioned for better profitability, which shows how one number can hide a land and cropping question.

Look at trends, not a single year. One year's benchmark can be thrown off by a weather event, a herd expansion or a milk price swing. Three years of your own numbers against the group's tell a more honest story.

Keep it private and practical

Benchmark data is sensitive. Share your detailed numbers with your lender, adviser and a trusted discussion group, not at the co-op coffee counter. Pair this work with an annual business review so the comparisons turn into decisions with dates attached.

Benchmarking can be heavy going, so when the spreadsheets have won for the day, farm.FM is a good place for dairy and farm humor.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: FINBIN, University of Minnesota · USDA ERS Milk Cost of Production Estimates · Cornell PRO-DAIRY

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.