Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Cash Flow Scenario Planner

Profit and cash are different animals. A dairy can finish the year in the black and still be unable to meet payroll in March because the feed bill, the loan payment and the tax estimate all landed together. A cash flow scenario planner finds those months before they find you.

Start with the monthly skeleton

Use twelve columns, one per month, and these rows.

  • Receipts: milk (after deductions), cull cows, calves, crop sales, government payments, other income.
  • Operating outflows: feed, labor, vet and breeding, supplies, fuel, repairs, utilities, insurance.
  • Financing outflows: interest and principal payments, lease payments.
  • Other outflows: tax payments, family living draw, capital purchases.
  • Net cash and ending balance for each month.

Milk is paid monthly, with a mid-month advance in many arrangements according to Penn State Extension, so the money from a month's milk may arrive in two pieces. Working capital has to bridge payroll and feed between payments. Put milk receipts in the month they actually arrive, not the month the cows gave the milk. If you also track the check itself, the monthly milk revenue budget covers that method.

Three price cases, built on one set of assumptions

Create three versions of the milk receipts row. Label them low, expected and high, and write the assumption at the top of each. Illustrative approach with made-up round numbers:

  1. Expected: use your trailing twelve-month average mailbox price, adjusted for what your buyer or cooperative tells you to expect.
  2. Low: take the expected price and subtract an amount you could believe, for example the drop from your own worst quarter in the last few years.
  3. High: add the same kind of amount.

Do not use a forecast you found online as a fact. Nobody, including this guide, can tell you next spring's price. The point is to see how your farm behaves across a range. The milk price volatility planning guide discusses ranges and how to pick them.

Next, decide which costs move. Feed often moves with the market, so a thorough planner gives each case its own feed assumption, or at least runs a second table with feed up and down. A simple 3 by 3 grid, three milk prices against three feed costs, gives nine ending-cash results for the year and a clear picture of which combination hurts.

Reading the results

For each case, look for four things.

  • The month with the lowest cash balance and how low it goes.
  • Whether the balance dips below zero or below the operating line limit.
  • Which months drive the problem. Often it is a pattern, such as spring when balancing fees tend to be higher according to Farm Credit East, or a month with an annual insurance and a land payment together.
  • Total cash at year end, compared with the start.

Seasonality in deductions is worth including. Farm Credit East says balancing deductions tend to be higher in spring and early summer when milk is plentiful and lower in fall, which affects monthly cash even when the annual price is flat.

What to do with a problem month

A negative month in the low case is information, not a verdict. Options to explore, each with trade-offs:

  • Time large purchases and inputs away from the tight month, where the seller allows it.
  • Arrange or enlarge an operating line before you need it. Banks are more receptive when the request comes with a plan. See preparing for a dairy loan conversation.
  • Look at risk tools that put a floor under margins. The FSA describes Dairy Margin Coverage as financial assistance when the margin between the all-milk price and average feed cost falls below the level you choose. Compare tools in DMC or Dairy Revenue Protection.
  • Talk with your cooperative or handler about payment terms.

Equity retains and deferred premiums are not cash. If your cooperative holds back equity, treat it as an illiquid asset when building the planner.

Updating it

Replace each month's estimate with the real number as it arrives and re-run the three cases for the months ahead. A planner updated monthly is a steering wheel. One built in January and left in a drawer is just a souvenir. Keep your accountant in the loop for the tax rows, because estimated payments depend on facts this guide cannot see.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check · USDA FSA Dairy Margin Coverage · Penn State Extension, Understanding Your Milk Check

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.