Dairy Break Even Price Worksheet
Most dairy farmers can quote the price they hope to get. Fewer can say, without hesitating, the price they need. The break-even price is that second number, and it is the most useful single figure you can carry into a conversation with a lender, a buyer or your own family at the kitchen table.
Two break-even prices, and why you need both
A break-even milk price is your total cost per hundredweight, less the income you earn from things other than milk. Everything turns on what you count as cost.
The cash break-even includes only costs you actually write checks for: feed, hired labor, vet, breeding, fuel, repairs, interest, insurance and taxes. It tells you the price below which you cannot pay your bills.
The full-cost break-even adds the costs that do not leave your account every month but are still real: depreciation, a wage for unpaid family labor and management, and a charge for the capital you own. It tells you the price below which the farm is slowly eating itself. USDA's Economic Research Service publishes milk cost of production estimates by state and herd size, and the way those numbers are built is a good model for sorting your own costs into these buckets.
A worked example with made-up round numbers
Suppose a 200-cow herd ships 4,400,000 pounds a year, which is 44,000 cwt. These figures are invented for the exercise and are not prices or benchmarks.
- Cash costs: $800,000
- Non-cash costs (depreciation, family labor, owned capital): $140,000
- Other income (cull cows, calves, custom work): $60,000
Cash break-even: ($800,000 minus $60,000) divided by 44,000 cwt is about $16.82 per cwt.
Full-cost break-even: ($940,000 minus $60,000) divided by 44,000 cwt is exactly $20.00 per cwt.
The gap of about $3.18 per cwt is the part of the farm that is not showing up as bills. A farm that clears the cash number but not the full number is not failing this year, but it is not replacing its barns, paying its family or building equity either. If you need help sorting costs, the guide to dairy production cost per hundredweight walks through the categories.
Compare it to the right price
The most common mistake is comparing break-even to the headline price announced by USDA. Your check is different. The number to hold against break-even is your mailbox price: what you actually receive after component tests, premiums, hauling, check-off and cooperative deductions. Why your mailbox price differs from the headline price explains the gap, and the Penn State Extension guide to understanding your milk check shows how to compute it from a statement.
Stress-testing the number
Break-even is not fixed. Run at least these three cases.
- Volume falls 5 percent. Shipments drop to 41,800 cwt while most costs stay put. Using the example costs, the full break-even rises from $20.00 to about $21.05 per cwt. Fixed costs get spread over fewer hundredweight.
- Feed rises 10 percent. If feed were $380,000 of the cash costs, that adds $38,000, or about $0.86 per cwt on 44,000 cwt. Test your own feed share.
- Components slip. A lower butterfat or protein test lowers revenue per cwt without lowering your costs, which feels like a higher break-even even though your costs did not move. Treat it as a revenue problem and track it separately.
Write the three results next to your base figure. If the full break-even in a bad case sits well above the price range you can reasonably expect, that is the signal to look at costs, volume or a risk tool before the cash runs out, not after.
Questions to take to your lender or adviser
- Does our cost per cwt include a family labor charge, and does the lender's version?
- Are we dividing by pounds shipped or pounds produced, and is the number the same in every spreadsheet?
- Which costs are truly fixed over the next 12 months, and which could we trim if the price drops?
- Would Dairy Margin Coverage change the effective price we need? The guide on comparing DMC and DRP is a good next read.
Revisit the worksheet each quarter. A break-even number that was right in January can be stale by July, and the farms that keep it fresh are the ones that are not surprised by the check.
Keep reading
- Income Over Feed Cost Guide
- Dairy Feed Cost and Milk Margin Worksheet
- Dairy Feed Market Volatility Worksheet
- Heifer Replacement Cost and Milk Prices
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: USDA ERS, Milk Cost of Production Estimates · Penn State Extension, Understanding Your Milk Check
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.