Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Income Over Feed Cost Guide

Ask a nutritionist how the herd is doing and you will often hear a number before you hear a diagnosis: income over feed cost. It is the simplest margin measure in dairy, and it is popular because both halves of the equation arrive in your mailbox every month.

The definition and the arithmetic

Income over feed cost, usually shortened to IOFC, is milk revenue minus feed cost. You can express it per cow per day, per cow per year or per hundredweight. The method is common practice among extension and farm business advisers rather than a regulated figure, so always say how you calculated yours.

Here is a made-up example. A cow averages 80 pounds of milk a day, and your mailbox price is $20.00 per cwt.

  • Milk revenue: 0.80 cwt times $20.00 is $16.00 per cow per day.
  • Feed cost: $7.20 per cow per day.
  • IOFC: $16.00 minus $7.20 is $8.80 per cow per day.

Per hundredweight, feed is $7.20 divided by 0.80, or $9.00, and IOFC is $20.00 minus $9.00, or $11.00 per cwt. The numbers are invented round figures, not market prices.

Decisions IOFC can inform

Because it ties revenue to the biggest controllable cost, IOFC is a good yardstick for several choices.

  • Comparing pens or groups. If high-group cows earn a much larger IOFC than late-lactation cows, you can see where a ration change pays and where it does not.
  • Testing a feed ingredient. A more expensive ingredient pays only if the extra milk or components lift revenue by more than the extra feed cost.
  • Watching trends. A falling IOFC with steady production means the milk price is slipping against feed, or feed is climbing against milk.

The feed cost and milk margin worksheet shows the same calculation at the whole-herd level, and the guide to feed market volatility shows what happens to it when ingredient prices swing.

What goes into feed cost and what comes out

Decide your convention and stick to it. Does feed cost cover only the milking herd, or also dry cows and heifers? Are home-raised forages valued at market price or at your cost to grow them? Penn State Extension's analysis of heifer budgets found that farms that match crop acres to animal numbers and grow competitive feed tend to be better positioned for profit, which is a reminder that the valuation of homegrown feed matters. See its dairy heifer cost variation summary for how those budgets were grouped.

If you compare your IOFC to a neighbor's, check that you both include the same animals and value feed the same way. Otherwise the comparison is noise.

Where IOFC misleads

IOFC leaves out everything that is not feed: labor, replacements, vet and breeding, hauling, interest, depreciation. A herd can post a strong IOFC and still lose money if labor and heifers are heavy. A herd with a modest IOFC can do well if its other costs are low.

It also uses the revenue that is easiest to compute, so check that revenue is the mailbox price and not the announced price. The two can differ by enough to change the story.

IOFC is also not the same as the margin in the federal program. FSA describes the Dairy Margin Coverage margin as the all-milk price minus an average feed cost, a national figure calculated by formula. Your own IOFC can be far above or below it. Read the details on the FSA Dairy Margin Coverage page and use your own numbers when deciding on coverage.

A simple monthly routine

  1. Pull pounds shipped and total milk revenue from the milk statement.
  2. Add feed invoices and the value of home-raised feed fed that month.
  3. Compute IOFC per cow per day and per cwt.
  4. Record it next to the previous three months and the same month last year.

After a year you will see the seasonal pattern, and after two you can start asking harder questions, such as whether the heifers are earning their keep. The guide to heifer replacement cost and milk prices is the natural next step.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: FSA, Dairy Margin Coverage Program · Penn State Extension, Dairy Heifer Cost Variation

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.