Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Labor, Land and Overhead in Dairy Cost Accounting

A young producer once told an adviser her cost of production was lower than the farm next door. Then the adviser asked who milked the 6 a.m. shift. She did, for no pay, and her husband did the 5 p.m. one. That is the most common hole in a dairy cost of production figure: the biggest inputs are the ones nobody writes a check for.

What the receipts do not show

Cash records capture feed, vet, fuel and hired labor. A full cost accounting adds items that never cross the checkbook.

  • Unpaid family labor. Operator and family hours at what it would cost to hire the work.
  • Management. A charge for the owner's time on records, marketing and decisions, separate from milking hours.
  • Owned land and capital. What the land, cows and equipment could earn elsewhere. Rent paid on leased ground is a cash cost, while owned ground has an opportunity cost.
  • Depreciation. Wear on buildings, parlor and machinery, which is real even in a year with no purchases.
  • Overhead. Insurance, taxes, utilities, accounting and office costs that serve the whole farm.

The cost categories USDA ERS works from include feed, replacement, labor, fuel and repairs, interest, depreciation, taxes, insurance and overhead. ERS estimates vary by state and size of operation, so they are a useful check on whether your own list is complete. When a published cost per cwt says whether it includes unpaid labor and owned-capital charges, believe it, because results differ widely depending on that choice.

A worked example with made-up numbers

Suppose a farm ships 20,000 cwt a year. These round figures are invented for illustration only.

  • Cash costs (feed, vet, hired labor, fuel, interest, taxes, insurance): $360,000.
  • Family labor: 5,000 hours at an assumed $18 an hour, or $90,000.
  • Depreciation: $30,000.
  • Charge for owned land and capital: $20,000.

Cash only: $360,000 / 20,000 cwt = $18.00 per cwt. Full cost: $500,000 / 20,000 = $25.00 per cwt. Neither number is wrong. They answer different questions. The cash figure tells you whether the milk check covers the bills this year. The full figure tells you whether the farm pays its family and replaces its assets in the long run. Our dairy production cost per hundredweight guide shows how to state both clearly.

How to account for each missing item

  1. Labor. Keep a simple log for two typical weeks per season. Count hours for everyone, then price them at a local hired wage. Ask your extension office what wage to use.
  2. Land. Use the local cash rent for similar ground as the charge for owned acres, and do not count both rent and a land charge on the same field.
  3. Depreciation. Your tax depreciation may run faster than real wear, so ask your accountant for an economic estimate, and keep the tax figure separate.
  4. Overhead. Add up every cost not tied to a single barn, then divide by cwt shipped.
  5. Management. Pick a modest, defensible figure and state it. Do not argue yourself to zero.

IRS Publication 225 notes that detailed records can show which enterprises are most profitable or where management changes are needed, and it expects farms to keep income and expense records by category. The same records feed your cost accounting, so categories chosen at the start save headaches later.

Where this matters in real decisions

Break-even work depends on it. If you compute break-even against cash costs only, you may sign a contract or sign a note that looks fine but leaves nothing for family living or equipment replacement. Compare the two results in the break-even price worksheet, and use the enterprise budget worksheet to split costs between milking cows, heifers and crops.

Heifers are a good test case. Penn State Extension says feed is about 60 percent of heifer-raising expense and labor is second at about 13 percent. If you leave out the labor, the calf barn looks cheaper than it is.

Questions for your lender or accountant

  • Which of these items does the lender count in debt service, and which does it ignore?
  • Which labor figure should we use for family members who also draw living expenses?
  • Are shared costs between the dairy and a crop or custom business split in a way we can defend?

Neither the farmer nor this guide can settle tax treatment. That is for your accountant or tax professional, with IRS Pub. 225 as the reference.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA ERS Milk Cost of Production Estimates · IRS Publication 225, Farmer's Tax Guide

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.