Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Production Cost per Hundredweight

Ask ten dairy farmers what it costs them to make a hundredweight of milk and you will get ten numbers, and at least four of them will leave out something important. The formula is simple. The discipline is in deciding what goes into the top line and what comes off.

The formula and the first decision

Cost per cwt equals total cost of the milk enterprise divided by total cwt sold. A per-cow version divides the same total by average cows. Both are useful, but only the per-cwt number can be set directly against a milk price, which is why it matters for decisions about contracts, risk coverage and expansion.

The first decision is which version of "cost" you are building. A cash version includes only what you paid out. A fuller economic version also charges for unpaid family labor, your own management, and the use of land and capital you own. USDA ERS publishes milk cost of production estimates that vary by state and by size of operation, and the fuller approach is the one that makes your number comparable with a published one. Whichever you pick, write it at the top of the page, because a cash cost and an economic cost can differ by a lot.

Worked example with made-up numbers

Suppose a farm sells 100,000 cwt a year. Costs for the year, in invented round dollars:

  • Purchased and home-raised feed: $1,100,000
  • Hired labor: $330,000
  • Replacement heifers (cost to raise or buy, spread across the herd): $300,000
  • Vet, breeding, supplies, bedding, utilities: $250,000
  • Fuel, repairs, custom work: $120,000
  • Interest and depreciation: $200,000
  • Taxes, insurance, overhead: $100,000

Cash and ownership total: $2,400,000, or $24.00 per cwt.

Now add a charge for unpaid family labor and management of, say, $120,000. The total becomes $2,520,000, or $25.20 per cwt. Same farm, same year, a $1.20 per cwt difference depending only on definitions.

Subtracting what is not milk

Dairy enterprises also sell cull cows, calves and sometimes manure or crops. Many analyses subtract these other revenues from total cost to get a net cost of producing milk. Say so on your sheet. If those sales are $250,000, the net cost in the example is $2,150,000 on cash and ownership terms, or $21.50 per cwt. Never mix methods when you compare: a net figure beside a gross one is not a comparison.

Common mistakes

  1. Dividing by pounds, not cwt. Convert first. See what is a hundredweight of milk.
  2. Leaving out replacements. Penn State Extension says replacement animals typically account for 15 to 20 percent of milk production costs, second or third among cost components. If you buy none and raise none on paper, your cost is understated.
  3. Treating family labor as free. Working owners are paid out of profit, which hides a real cost.
  4. Using cash taxes and depreciation unevenly. Tax depreciation and economic depreciation can differ; talk to your accountant about which number to use for management.
  5. Using the wrong sales number. Use cwt sold, not cwt produced, and note milk dumped or fed to calves.
  6. One year only. A single odd year can mislead. Use three years where you can.

Using the number

Compare your per-cwt cost with the mailbox price from your statements, not with a headline price. The gap between them, over a full year, is your margin before owner labor and return to capital. The break-even price worksheet takes this cost and turns it into a minimum price you need, and the enterprise budget worksheet shows the line-by-line layout. If you are not sure how to treat labor, land and overhead, see labor, land and overhead in dairy cost accounting.

Your lender, extension farm management specialist or a farm business summary program can sanity-check your categories. FINBIN, from the University of Minnesota, describes benchmark reports that compare your farm to a group of similar farms, which is a cleaner reference than a single published average. Treat cost per cwt as a trend you track each year, with a note on every change in method, and it becomes one of the most useful numbers in the business.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA ERS, Milk Cost of Production Estimates · Penn State Extension, Heifer Economics · FINBIN, University of Minnesota

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.