Milk Price Projection Versus Realized Comparison
Most farm budgets begin with a milk price somebody wrote down in December. By October that number looks either brilliant or embarrassing, and memory quietly edits it. The cure is a simple scorecard kept from the day the projection is made.
Freeze the projection
A projection only teaches you something if you can prove what it said. When you build a budget, write down on one page:
- The date and the source: a USDA outlook, a university projection, a futures quote, your co-op, or your own guess.
- The exact price series: Class III, an all-milk figure, or your expected mailbox price. Say which.
- The unit, per cwt, and the months covered.
- One sentence on why you chose it.
USDA's Economic Research Service posts a monthly Livestock, Dairy, and Poultry Outlook based on the latest WASDE, and notes that its pages should be read live for current forecasts. If you used a published outlook, save the issue date. Release dates for the WASDE are posted in advance by USDA; check the schedule rather than guessing.
Score against the right actual
The commonest scoring error is comparing a class price projection with a mailbox result and calling the difference "forecast error." Split it in two:
- Market error: projected announced price minus the announced price AMS later published. AMS says the monthly class and advanced price announcements are not revised, so this actual is firm.
- Farm gap: announced price minus your own mailbox price. That is basis, the topic of the basis guide, and it is more stable than the market error. The method for tracking it is in the futures versus receipts article.
Illustrative round numbers only: suppose a budget assumed 20.00 per cwt for a month, the announced price came out at 18.50, and the farm's mailbox price was 17.80. The market missed by 1.50 and the farm gap was 0.70. Those are two lessons, not one. Do not read the numbers as prices for any real month.
Build the table
Make a row per month and these columns: projected price, announced price, market error, mailbox price, farm gap. After twelve months, look at three things:
- Direction. Were you high or low most months? Consistent bias is fixable.
- Size. How large were errors on average, ignoring sign? That tells you how wide a range to use.
- Timing. Was the miss bigger for months far out? Longer horizons are usually harder, which argues for ranges instead of single numbers in a budget forecast.
Keep hindsight honest
Three habits protect you from yourself.
First, never edit the original projection row. Add a note column for what you learned instead. Second, record what you did because of the projection: sold a contract, held cash, delayed a purchase. Judge the decision by the information at the time, as well as by the outcome. A decision can be sound and still lose money. Third, include months where you were right for the wrong reason.
Using the result
After a year you will have a rough error band. Build your next budget with three cases, low, expected and high, using that band, then run each through the cash flow scenario planner. If your lender asks how you set your price assumption, a log showing last year's projections and what happened is more persuasive than any number.
For student projects, this is a good small study: compare one published outlook with the announced prices that followed and report the average miss. Cite the source and issue date of every projection, and do not present the study as a forecast of future prices.
Keep reading
- Regional Dairy Market Comparison Worksheet
- Dairy Herd Inventory Statistics Research
- Dairy Sales Volume Annual Summary
- Reading a Dairy Market News Weekly Report
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: USDA ERS Dairy Market Outlook · USDA AMS Class and Component Price Announcement · USDA ERS Dairy Data
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.