Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Milk Futures Versus Farm Milk Receipts

A producer sells Class III futures at a price that looks great, then watches the month end and finds the milk check came in well under the number she locked. Nothing went wrong with the contract. She compared two things that were never the same.

Four numbers that get confused

Picture a single month and four prices that all get called "the milk price":

  1. The futures settlement. CME Class III and Class IV futures are cash-settled to the price USDA announces for that contract month, quoted in dollars per hundredweight.
  2. The announced class price. AMS publishes it after the month, built from weekly product price survey averages and formulas.
  3. The order's blend price. The market administrator's uniform price is the class price plus the PPD, adjusted to your plant's location.
  4. Your mailbox price. What you actually received per cwt after premiums and deductions.

UW Extension says CME futures and USDA-announced Class III and IV prices tend to move together because they respond to the same cheese, butter, powder and whey fundamentals, but they are separate markets. Extension also notes the individual mailbox price can run above or below Class III depending on component tests, and that the gap between a hedge or insurance index and your farm's result is basis risk the producer keeps.

A fair comparison, step by step

Use made-up round numbers to see the structure. Suppose a farm ships 100,000 pounds in a month, which is 1,000 cwt. It sold futures covering part of that milk at a settlement the farm considers a good price.

  1. Convert units first. A Class III contract is 200,000 pounds, or 2,000 cwt, quoted per cwt. Check the price unit guide if cents per pound or dollars per cwt ever tangle.
  2. Write the futures price and the announced Class III price for the same contract month. Difference one is the futures result against the USDA settlement.
  3. Pull your order's blend price from the AMS statistics or your handler. The gap between Class III and blend is the PPD, covered in the PPD guide.
  4. Add your premiums and subtract hauling and other deductions to reach your mailbox price from your statement.
  5. Compute your own gap: mailbox price minus announced Class III. That is your farm's basis for the month, in the sense Penn State Extension uses it: the usual gap between the check and announced Class III, reflecting component values, premiums and order benefits.

Do this for twelve months. The average gap, and how much it bounces, is the planning number. Penn State notes that expected basis plus the futures price gives a planning price, and that a contract priced "at Class III" still leaves the PPD basis with you.

Why your gap is not your neighbor's

Component tests are the most common reason neighboring farms differ. Premium schedules, pooling on different orders and contract terms add to it. Hauling is negotiated, not set by the order. So copy a method from a neighbor, not a number.

Traps in the comparison

  • Comparing a futures price on one day with a check for a different month.
  • Forgetting the futures gain or loss sits in a brokerage account, not on the milk statement. The mailbox price does not include forward contracts or advances, per Penn State.
  • Judging a hedge by one month. A hedge protects against a falling price over time; a single month where the check beat the hedge is not evidence it was a mistake.
  • Ignoring that a futures contract can be larger than a small farm's monthly milk. Penn State's example is a 100-cow herd at 70 pounds a day shipping about 217,000 pounds a month, barely over one contract.

For the next step, read how CME contracts work and the basis explainer, then talk with your co-op, a broker or an extension economist before putting any money behind a position. This article explains concepts and is not trading advice.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: UW Extension: dairy price risk management tools · Penn State Extension: using milk futures to lock in profitability · CME Group: Introduction to Dairy Futures and Options

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.