Regional Dairy Market Comparison Worksheet
A dairy in the Upper Midwest and one in the Southeast can both ship milk and still live in very different price worlds. Anyone thinking about expanding, moving, switching plants or just settling a debate at the co-op meeting needs a way to compare regions without cherry-picking. Here is a structure that fits on a page.
Decide what you are comparing
Pick one question, such as "Would a similar farm net more per cwt in region B than in region A?" Then compare on five fronts, in this order.
1. Which order, and which class mix
Most US milk is marketed under Federal Milk Marketing Orders, a small share under similar state programs and some under neither, according to ERS. AMS lists states with their own classified pricing programs: Maine, Montana, Nevada, New York, North Dakota, Pennsylvania and Virginia. Start by naming the order or state program for each region. Then look at utilization by class. UW Extension notes the Upper Midwest has low Class I utilization, so its blend runs close to Class III and its PPD is small in size, while regions with more fluid use behave differently. AMS publishes utilization and uniform prices by order in its marketing order statistics.
2. Component levels
Per-cwt prices only compare fairly at the same test. A farm with higher butterfat and protein earns more under component pricing, as the component pricing guide explains. UW says component tests are the most common reason neighboring farms see different mailbox prices. Compare regions at the same fat and protein, or compare dollars per pound of components.
3. Location adjustments
Milk is priced at the plant where it is first physically received, and class prices and the PPD are adjusted for plant location. Class I differentials are listed county by county in 7 CFR 1000.52, and AMS posts an effective-differentials spreadsheet. Penn State and Cornell material notes that location gains can be offset by hauling cost.
4. Hauling
Hauling is negotiated among farms, haulers and handlers, and the orders do not regulate it. UW's quick reference gives a rule of thumb of about one cent per cwt per mile as a planning approximation, not a quote, and a May 2025 snapshot showing the Upper Midwest order's weighted average deduction at $0.51 per cwt, with lower charges where plants are dense and higher where farms are scattered. Check the hauling deduction guide and ask for your own tariff.
5. Basis and premiums
Compare the gap between announced price and mailbox price for farms in each region, as in the basis guide. Premium programs for volume, quality and components are set by plants and co-ops, not by orders.
Write it in prose
For each region, write four sentences: the order and class mix, typical component levels as published by AMS or your extension office, hauling norms, and what premiums your handler type usually pays. Then write one sentence on the largest difference. This forces a conclusion and exposes what you do not know.
Where comparisons go wrong
- Comparing a class price in one region to a mailbox price in another.
- Using a dated example, such as an old hauling table, as a current rate.
- Ignoring cost differences in feed, land, labor and regulation, which can swamp a few cents of price. See production cost per cwt.
- Treating a thin market as if it had options. A farm with one plant in reach has one bid, whatever the table says.
Before acting, call the market administrator's office for each order, an extension dairy specialist and, for any move, a lender. The state directory can help you find those contacts.
Keep reading
- Dairy Herd Inventory Statistics Research
- Dairy Sales Volume Annual Summary
- Reading a Dairy Market News Weekly Report
- Global Dairy Trade Auctions and Farm Milk Prices
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: USDA AMS Marketing Order Statistics · UW Extension: Milk Hauling Quick Reference · USDA ERS Dairy Policy
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.