Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Farm Budget Forecast Exercise

A budget is a set of decisions written as numbers. The forecast exercise below uses invented round figures so you can practice the method, then swap in your own records. None of the numbers here is a market price or a prediction.

The three drivers

Nearly every dairy budget is built on three drivers, and weak assumptions on any one can sink the result.

  1. Volume. Cows milking times pounds per cow per day times days.
  2. Price. The mailbox price you expect to net after deductions.
  3. Cost. Feed, labor, replacement, vet, fuel, repairs, interest and the rest.

Write each as an assumption on its own line with a source: "Average 100 cows, from the last twelve months of inventory," or "Mailbox price from the trailing year, less a margin of caution." Assumptions with no source are guesses dressed up as plans.

Worked example

Suppose a farm milks 100 cows and ships 80 pounds per cow per day, for 365 days.

  • Volume: 100 x 80 x 365 = 2,920,000 pounds, or 29,200 cwt.
  • Price: assume a net mailbox price of $20.00 per cwt, a round number chosen only for the exercise.
  • Milk revenue: 29,200 x $20.00 = $584,000.
  • Other revenue: cull cows and calves, say $60,000.
  • Total revenue: $644,000.

Costs, also made up:

  • Feed: $260,000.
  • Labor (hired and family at a stated wage): $110,000.
  • Replacement, vet and breeding: $75,000.
  • Fuel, repairs, utilities, insurance: $90,000.
  • Interest and depreciation: $70,000.
  • Total: $605,000.

Projected margin: $39,000. As a cost per cwt, $605,000 / 29,200 = about $20.72, a bit over the assumed price, so the surplus comes from the non-milk income. That detail is the sort of thing a budget should force you to see. If the farm wrongly believed its milk covered its costs on its own, it would be surprised later.

Stress-test the forecast

A single-point forecast is fragile. Change one driver at a time and record the result.

  • Price down 5 percent: milk revenue falls by $29,200 and the margin shrinks to about $9,800.
  • Volume down 3 percent from a herd health problem: the loss is larger than it looks because most costs stay fixed.
  • Feed up 10 percent: an added $26,000, which would push the margin negative.

Pair those into a table of nine cells, as described in the dairy cash flow scenario planner, and note which cells fall below zero. Those are the cells you should plan for with a tool, a reserve or a cost lever. The farm-level revenue sensitivity analysis goes deeper on price and component swings.

Check against outside data

Compare your cost assumptions against USDA ERS milk cost of production estimates, which vary by state and size of operation, and against FINBIN benchmark reports for farms like yours. If your feed cost per cwt differs wildly from both, find out why before you commit to the budget. Penn State Extension's analysis also shows replacement costs are driven mostly by age at first calving and herd turnover, so a forecast that assumes a high cull rate and a long raising period needs matching heifer costs.

Common mistakes

  • Forecasting revenue on the announced price instead of your own mailbox price, which includes deductions and your component tests.
  • Leaving out unpaid labor and then wondering why the budget cannot pay a family draw.
  • Using last year's hot or cold result as the expected case.
  • Ignoring timing. A budget can be positive and still run out of cash, which is why the monthly view matters. See the monthly milk revenue budget.

Doing it for real

Run the exercise first on paper with these figures. Then replace each assumption with your own, one line at a time, and keep a note of where each came from. Review the result with your accountant or adviser, and update it when real numbers arrive. If you are a student or in a youth project, the same method works on a single project animal or a small enterprise, scaled down.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA ERS Milk Cost of Production Estimates · FINBIN, University of Minnesota · Penn State Extension, Heifer Economics

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.