Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Understanding Basis in Dairy Markets

A farmer hears that Class III futures for next spring are at a number he likes, sells nothing, and then wonders in April why his check is lower than that number. The missing piece is basis, and it is the reason a futures price is a starting point rather than a promise.

What basis means in milk

TAMU Extension defines basis as the difference between the cash price and the futures price, so futures plus basis is the expected cash price. Milk is a little unusual. TAMU notes that milk basis can be figured on a gross or a mailbox price, and that it reflects season, location, quality and milk use rather than grade and transportation alone.

Penn State frames it for dairy producers: your basis is the usual gap between your milk check and the announced Class III price, and it reflects component values, marketing premiums and the benefits of the federal order. Progressive Dairy puts it as the difference between an announced price and the price the farmer actually receives. Different wording, same idea.

Why yours differs from your neighbor's

Several things sit between the announced price and your mailbox:

  • Your butterfat, protein and other solids tests against the average
  • The PPD for your plant location
  • Premiums for volume, quality or components
  • Hauling, check-off, cooperative charges and equity retains
  • Being in a different order, or shipping to a handler that depools

UW Extension also warns that CME Class III futures and the realized federal order Class III price are not the same number, and that gaps between a hedge or insurance index and your own result are basis risk, which you keep.

Measuring your own basis

You need monthly data. Use this routine:

  1. Calculate your mailbox price: premium and component dollars less all deductions, divided by total pounds, times 100. Farm Credit East uses that method.
  2. Write down the announced Class III price for the same month from the AMS class announcement.
  3. Subtract: mailbox minus Class III. A negative result is a weak basis; a positive one is strong.
  4. Repeat for at least 12 months, then for each calendar month across years if you have the records.

Here is a made-up illustration. If your last six months of gaps were minus $0.40, minus $0.60, minus $0.20, minus $0.50, minus $0.90 and minus $0.30, the average is minus $0.48. Round that to a planning basis of about minus $0.50 and notice that your worst month was almost double the best. Those figures are teaching numbers only.

Penn State cautions that the mailbox price does not include advance payments, forward contracts or assignments, so keep those out of the comparison. A cooperative may also offer a basis contract protecting the whole milk check, not only the Class III value.

Using basis in planning

An expected basis plus a futures price gives a planning price. Suppose a made-up futures price of $19.00 and an expected basis of minus $0.50; the planning price is $18.50 per cwt. Compare that with your budget in the monthly milk revenue budget. If your breakeven sits above it, that is information worth having before you commit to anything.

Two cautions. Basis is not constant, so use a range, not a single figure. And a price contract at Class III still leaves you with the gap between the blend and Class III, which is the PPD, a risk the PPD guide explains.

Questions for your co-op or broker

Ask what the contract is priced against, whether any fee comes off the futures price, and what happens to the deductions. A licensed broker or your cooperative can explain contract terms; this article cannot give investment advice. For a gentle on-ramp to the market itself, read CME dairy futures for beginners, and for pricing steps see Penn State's guide on using milk futures.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: Penn State Extension Using Milk Futures · TAMU Extension Milk Marketing Basis · UW Extension Dairy Price Risk Management Tools

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.