Understanding Make Allowances
Here is a sentence that explains a lot of recent dairy arguments: a cheese plant does not get to keep the whole cheese price, and the milk formula knows it. The piece subtracted for the plant's cost of turning milk into product is the make allowance.
What the term means
The federal order formulas start with a surveyed wholesale price for cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk or dry whey. Before that price becomes a value for milk components, a fixed amount per pound is subtracted to cover the processor's manufacturing cost. That subtraction is the make allowance. Look at 7 CFR 1000.50 and you will see it in every component price, for example the butterfat price is the butter survey price less 22.72 cents, times 1.211.
So the allowance is a feature of the formula, not a charge on any one farm. Everyone in an order faces the same formula.
Why USDA changed them
Per the Congressional Research Service, make allowances had not been updated since 2008 before the 2025 amendments. Plant costs had moved, and a stale allowance means a formula that assumes a plant spends less than it does. USDA took the question up at the national pricing hearing in Carmel, Indiana, which ran from August 23, 2023 to January 30, 2024. The final decision came on November 12, 2024, and producers in each of the 11 orders approved the amendments in referenda. The final rule took effect June 1, 2025, with composition factor changes following on December 1, 2025.
The final decision also added a $0.0015 marketing cost factor to all make allowances and revised the method for the nonfat dry milk allowance, per AMS's FAQ.
Old and new, per pound
AMS's timeline lists these changes:
- Cheese: $0.2003 to $0.2519
- Butter: $0.1715 to $0.2272
- Nonfat dry milk: $0.1678 to $0.2393
- Dry whey: $0.1991 to $0.2668
The first announcement using the new allowances and block-only cheese was the July 2, 2025 class announcement for June milk.
What it does to a check
As plain arithmetic, a higher allowance subtracts more from the product price before it becomes a component value, so, other things equal, component prices come out lower. A made-up example: a $2.00 per pound product price with a $0.20 allowance leaves $1.80, and with a $0.25 allowance leaves $1.75. That nickel then gets multiplied by yield factors and by every pound of component you ship.
But "other things equal" never holds in a real month. The same package raised composition factors, which increase the pounds of protein, other solids and nonfat solids credited per hundredweight of skim, and it restored the higher-of Class I mover, which can lift the blend. The CRS notes that the regulatory analysis estimated an average increase of about 1.2 percent in producer revenue and pool values using 2019 through 2023 data. That is an estimate on history, not a promise for any month or any farm. The way these changes reach a check is traced in how the 2025 federal order changes reach your milk check.
Common mistakes
- Treating the allowance as what your plant "really" spends. It is a regulatory figure set by rulemaking, not an audit of one plant.
- Blaming the allowance for a drop in a single month. Product prices, the PPD and your own tests usually move more.
- Comparing checks from before and after June 2025 without noting the formula era. AMS divides formulas into through May 2025, June to November 2025, and December 2025 on.
Where to check
AMS posts price formulas and worksheets by class, and a cost-of-processing page tied to this issue. If you want to follow how the rules evolve, the federal order hearing overview shows how proposals, hearings and referenda work, and Class III prices shows the allowances in a full calculation. For the formal record, read the AMS pricing hearing page.
Keep reading
- Understanding Milk Component Pricing
- Understanding Basis in Dairy Markets
- Dairy Producer Price Differential Guide
- How to Read the Uniform Milk Price
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: eCFR 7 CFR 1000.50 · AMS National FMMO Pricing Hearing · Congressional Research Service on FMMOs
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.