Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Federal Milk Marketing Order Hearing Overview

A federal order hearing is the one moment when a rule that moves your milk check is argued in public, with a transcript. The last national one ran 49 days. Most farmers never attended a minute of it, yet its outcome changed their price formulas. Knowing the sequence tells you when your voice carries weight.

The sequence, with the national example

AMS lists the stages of a national proceeding as petitions, a USDA action plan, a notice of hearing, the hearing, post-hearing briefs, a recommended decision, a comment period, a final decision, a referendum and a final rule. The recent national case shows the pace.

  • AMS posted petitions and a USDA action plan with a request for additional proposals on June 1, 2023.
  • The hearing was noticed in the Federal Register in July 2023 and ran from August 23, 2023 to January 30, 2024 in Carmel, Indiana, covering 21 proposals.
  • Post-hearing briefs were due April 1, 2024.
  • The recommended decision issued July 1, 2024 and opened a 60-day comment period that ended September 13, 2024 with 128 comments.
  • The final decision issued November 12, 2024.
  • Producers voted in referenda on each order, and the final rule was issued in January 2025.

AMS says its general rulemaking can take anywhere from one to several years, depending on complexity and participation. The AMS hearing page keeps the exhibits, transcripts, guidelines and webinars for anyone to read.

What happens in the room

Under the Agricultural Marketing Agreement Act, the Secretary must give due notice and an opportunity for a hearing on a proposed order. At the hearing, proponents explain each proposal, witnesses testify and are questioned, and exhibits go into the record. USDA decides from that record, which is why AMS calls the process transparent and record-based.

Participation is open. AMS describes the process as all-inclusive, so any interested person can take part, though in practice cooperatives, processors and trade groups bring most witnesses. If you are an individual farmer, your options are to attend, to ask your cooperative how it plans to represent members, or to read the transcript for testimony on your issue. Hearing procedures and guidelines are posted with the notice, so read those before planning anything. For procedural questions the AMS page lists the Hearing Clerk as the keeper of official copies.

After the hearing: where farmers have the most say

Two later steps are easier for a working farmer than the hearing.

First, the comment period on the recommended decision. Comments become part of the record and the final decision responds to them. The public comment research guide covers how to find the docket and what to include.

Second, the referendum. Approval needs at least two-thirds of producers voting, or producers of two-thirds of the milk represented. Eligible voters in 2024 and 2025 were producers whose milk was pooled in January 2024. Cooperatives may bloc vote for members, and members of cooperatives that do not bloc vote get ballots themselves. Producers vote on the whole order, not on single provisions. Details are in how producers vote in federal order referendums.

What changed in the end

The final decision differed from the recommended decision in several ways, including a marketing cost factor of $0.0015 in the make allowances and a six-month rather than twelve-month delay for composition factors. That shows comments and testimony can move the result. For the content of the changes, see federal order reform research.

A practical way to follow along

Sign up for AMS notices, bookmark the proceeding page, and read the Federal Register notice with the help of how to read a Federal Register notice about dairy. Ask your cooperative's board or field staff how they will vote on proposals before the hearing, not after the referendum ballot arrives.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA AMS National FMMO Pricing Hearing · USDA AMS Final Decision FAQ · USDA AMS FMMO Referendum Handout

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.