Milk Price And Dairy Policy

How 2025 Federal Order Changes Reach Your Milk Check

Nobody gets a milk check that says "2025 order amendments" on it. The changes arrive as slightly different numbers on lines you already see every month, which makes them easy to miss and easy to blame for the wrong thing. Here is the path from the rule to the paper, kept to what USDA has published.

What actually changed

AMS and the final rule describe four groups of changes:

  • Make allowances rose. Per pound, cheese went from $0.2003 to $0.2519, butter from $0.1715 to $0.2272, nonfat dry milk from $0.1678 to $0.2393 and dry whey from $0.1991 to $0.2668, according to AMS's timeline of changes. CRS notes they had not been updated since 2008.
  • Milk composition factors rose. True protein from 3.1 to 3.3 percent, other solids from 5.9 to 6.0 percent, and nonfat solids from 9.0 to 9.3 percent.
  • The survey changed. The 500-pound barrel cheese price was removed, so the monthly cheese price relies on 40-pound blocks alone.
  • The Class I mover changed. The base Class I skim milk price returned to the higher-of the advanced Class III or Class IV skim prices, replacing the "average-of plus $0.74" approach from the 2018 farm bill. Class I differentials were also updated by county.

The calendar matters

Most provisions took effect June 1, 2025. The composition factor changes waited until December 1, 2025. AMS's timeline says the July 2, 2025 announcement for June milk was the first to use the new make allowances and block-only cheese, and the announcements for December milk were the first to use the new composition factors. So a statement for a 2025 month sits in one of three formula eras: through May, June through November, or December onward. If you compare checks across that boundary, note which era each month belongs to.

Where each change lands on the statement

Think in terms of line items rather than formula names.

Component prices. In multiple component pricing orders, your check pays on butterfat, protein and other solids. Make allowances are subtracted inside the product-to-component formulas, so by themselves a higher allowance tends to push component values down, all else equal. The composition factors work the other way, because they change how many pounds of protein and solids the formulas credit to each hundredweight. These two effects do not net out the same way every month, which is why you should not expect a simple before-and-after comparison to isolate either.

The PPD line. The producer price differential is the gap between the order's blend value and the Class III value. UW Extension's explanation of the order system ties the older average-of mover to some very negative PPDs during 2020-2023, and that was a motive for the rewrite. A higher-of mover raises the Class I value that flows into the pool. Whether your PPD line looks better in a given month still depends on utilization and class price spreads.

Orders that use skim-fat pricing. UW Extension says Appalachian, Arizona, Florida and Southeast pay on a skim price and a butterfat price, so those checks show fewer lines but the same underlying formulas.

A way to check your own paper

  1. Pull one statement from before June 2025, one from June to November, and one from December onward.
  2. Mark the announced butterfat, protein and other solids prices from the AMS announcements for each month. Compare them with the component pricing guide.
  3. Compare pounds of each component on your check with your lab tests, using reading your milk statement line by line.
  4. Note the PPD line and read what the PPD means before assuming a rule caused a swing.
  5. Ask your handler or co-op for a written explanation of any deduction or adjustment you cannot match to a published price.

Expect honest limits. CRS reports a USDA analysis estimated an average increase of about 1.2 percent in producer revenue and pool values, using historical 2019-2023 data. That is an average over many farms, not a forecast for yours. Your own outcome depends on your components, your order, your handler's premiums and what markets do. For a closer look at the formula pieces, see understanding make allowances.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: AMS Timeline for Changes to Price Announcements · AMS, USDA Issues Final Decision on Amendments to All Eleven Federal Milk Marketing Orders · CRS, Federal Milk Marketing Orders · UW Extension, Federal Milk Marketing Orders 101

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.