Understanding Milk Component Pricing
Two farms ship the same 100,000 pounds of milk in the same month to the same plant, and one check is a couple thousand dollars larger. Component pricing is usually the reason, and it is the most useful thing a producer can learn about the milk check.
Two ways to pay for milk
UW Extension reports that seven federal orders use multiple component pricing, or MCP: Upper Midwest, Northeast, Mideast, Central, California, Pacific Northwest and Southwest. Four use skim-fat pricing: Appalachian, Arizona, Florida and Southeast. Under MCP, producers are paid for pounds of butterfat, protein and other solids plus the producer price differential. Under skim-fat, they are paid on a uniform skim milk price and a butterfat price, without separate protein and other solids values. Confirm your order's method in its own part of the CFR or with your market administrator.
From test to dollars
Penn State Extension lays out the method in plain steps:
- Pounds of a component equal the test percent times pounds of milk shipped.
- Revenue equals pounds of the component times the announced monthly price per pound.
- Add the PPD per hundredweight, then any premiums, and subtract deductions.
Here is a made-up example, labeled as such. Farm A ships 100,000 pounds at 4.0 percent butterfat, 3.1 percent protein and 5.7 percent other solids. That is 4,000 pounds of fat, 3,100 of protein and 5,700 of other solids. Farm B ships the same volume at 3.6, 2.9 and 5.7, which is 3,600, 2,900 and 5,700 pounds. Assume round component prices of $2.50 per pound fat, $2.00 protein and $0.30 other solids.
- Farm A: 10,000 + 6,200 + 1,710 = $17,920, or $17.92 per cwt before PPD.
- Farm B: 9,000 + 5,800 + 1,710 = $16,510, or $16.51 per cwt before PPD.
Same milk volume, a $1,410 gap, entirely from tests. Those are teaching numbers, not market prices.
Why every farm sees the same prices but a different check
The component prices are announced monthly by USDA and apply to every producer in an order. What differs is the test, plus premiums and deductions. UW says lower or higher tests, handler decisions on depooling, different premium schedules, different hauling and being in a different order are the usual reasons neighbors differ, with component tests the most common. Penn State adds that the producer controls volume, components, somatic cell count and milk quality, and cannot change the announced prices.
Butterfat and protein typically make up the biggest share of check value under MCP, UW notes, with other solids smaller.
Where the formulas come from
The component prices come from the class formulas in 7 CFR 1000.50: butterfat from the butter survey, protein from the block cheese survey, other solids from the whey survey, each less a make allowance. Those values are used for all pooled milk in an MCP order, not only milk that becomes cheese. See understanding Class III milk prices for the math, and make allowances for the deduction.
Two practical habits
First, compute your components in pounds every month, not only the percentages. A test that slips 0.1 point sounds trivial until you multiply it by a month of shipments. Second, tie your check to the announcement. Farm Credit East advises that prices on the check should match the monthly pool price announcement. If your handler's component prices do not match the AMS Announcement of Class and Component Prices, ask why.
If you are pooled under skim-fat pricing, your check will not show protein and other solids separately, but your butterfat and skim price still come from the same formulas, and your test still matters. A feed or breeding change that raises components is worth pricing out against your order's rules. A good starting point is the milk check line by line guide, and the component yield and revenue exercise works through more scenarios. To see how UW suggests reading a statement, use its milk check walkthrough.
Keep reading
- Understanding Basis in Dairy Markets
- Dairy Producer Price Differential Guide
- How to Read the Uniform Milk Price
- Milk Price per Pound and per Cwt Conversion
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: UW Extension Reading the Milk Check · Penn State Extension Understanding Your Milk Check · eCFR 7 CFR 1000.50
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.