Recordkeeping for Dairy Taxes and Lenders
A shoebox of receipts and a stack of milk statements will get a tax return filed. They will not answer the question a lender asks in March: what did a hundredweight cost you to produce last year? The good news is that a tax preparer and a loan officer want most of the same raw material, so one well-built system can serve both.
What each reader is looking for
IRS Publication 225 says that farm records help you monitor how the business is doing, prepare financial statements, identify the source of receipts, track deductible expenses, prepare tax returns and support items reported on them. The IRS also says the law does not require any particular kind of records except in a few cases, so the system should suit your farm and clearly show income and expenses.
A lender reads the same numbers differently. Pub. 225 notes records are needed to prepare financial statements, including income statements, cash flow statements and balance sheets, which are required and useful when you work with a bank or creditors. The lender wants to see trend, repayment ability and what the milk check really nets after deductions.
So the tax side asks "what is deductible and provable?" and the credit side asks "what does this farm earn and can it repay?" Same receipts, two questions.
A single system with four layers
- Source documents. Milk statements, feed tickets, vet invoices, breeding bills, fuel receipts, bills of sale. The IRS says to keep invoices as well as canceled checks or account statements, because proof of payment alone does not establish a deduction.
- A summary ledger. Whether a spreadsheet, a farm accounting package or a bookkeeper's file, it should list every transaction by date, category and enterprise. Pub. 225 describes a system with a summary of business transactions plus supporting documents organized by year and by type of income or expense.
- An asset file. For each purchased cow group, parlor upgrade or machine, the IRS says to keep acquisition date and cost, improvements, depreciation taken, how it was used and disposal details.
- A herd and production log. Pounds shipped, tests, cows milking, heifers raised. Lenders and benchmarking tools use this to turn dollars into cost per hundredweight.
Keep the milk check as its own category with gross value and deductions recorded separately. A lender comparing your mailbox price with the announced price needs to see the deductions, and the milk check monthly audit shows a simple way to capture them each month.
Details that trip dairies up
- Mixed enterprises. The IRS advises a separate, complete set of records for each business if you run more than one. A dairy that also runs a custom hay business or a farm store should not blend them.
- Livestock accounting. Pub. 225 says livestock held for dairy purposes can be either depreciated or included in inventory, while livestock held primarily for sale must be in inventory. Which approach fits your herd is a question for your tax professional, not a spreadsheet.
- Cooperative paperwork. Equity statements and retains are not cash. Keep them filed with the year they relate to and tell your lender what is and is not available for debt service.
- Electronic records. Publication 583 covers bookkeeping systems, and the IRS says they must be indexed, stored, preserved, retrievable and reproducible in legible form, and are subject to the same retention rules.
This article explains record categories only. Tax treatment depends on your entity, your accounting method and the year, so use the current edition of Pub. 225 and a tax professional for decisions.
How long to keep things
The IRS says to keep records supporting income or deductions until the period of limitations runs out, generally at least 3 years from when the return was due or filed, or 2 years from when the tax was paid, whichever is later. Employment tax records generally need at least 4 years. Asset records should stay until the limitations period expires for the year you dispose of the property, and basis records may need to be kept longer.
The IRS also cautions against discarding records without checking whether insurers or creditors need them longer. A loan agreement may set its own requirements, so ask your lender before clearing out the filing cabinet. The guide on dairy financial record retention gives a practical schedule to build around.
Making it pay off at the bank
Once the ledger is clean, the same data feeds a dairy farm business annual review and a lender meeting. For that conversation, see preparing for a dairy loan conversation. Records you can hand over in an hour tend to make a better impression than records you promise to find.
Keep reading
- Preparing for a Dairy Loan Conversation
- Dairy Cash Flow Scenario Planner
- Dairy Cash Reserve Planner
- Dairy Farm Budget Forecast Exercise
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: IRS Publication 225, Farmer's Tax Guide · IRS Publication 583, Starting a Business and Keeping Records · Farm Credit East, understanding your milk check
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.