Preparing for a Dairy Loan Conversation
The loan officer has read plenty of milk-price headlines already. What the meeting is really about is whether you understand your own numbers well enough to survive a bad year. Farmers who walk in with a clear picture of costs, cash flow and price risk tend to have a better conversation than those who walk in hoping the market turns.
What to put in the folder
FSA's description of operating loans gives a useful view of what lenders generally want. Its page says applications need detailed financial and production information and a farm business plan, and that applicants must show the ability to repay. Commercial lenders and Farm Credit institutions ask for similar material, though each has its own list, so call ahead and ask for it.
A solid folder usually includes:
- Recent income statements and a current balance sheet. IRS Pub. 583 describes an income statement as income and expenses for a period and a balance sheet as assets, liabilities and equity on a given date.
- A monthly cash flow projection for the coming year, built from your seasonal pattern, not a twelfth of the annual total.
- Twelve to 36 months of milk statements, with gross value and deductions broken out so the lender can see the mailbox price.
- Production data: cows milking, pounds shipped, component tests, somatic cell count.
- Cost of production per hundredweight and your break-even price, with the method explained.
- Your risk plan: which programs you enrolled in, any contracts or hedges, and who you talk to about them.
Records you maintain all year make this easy. If they do not exist yet, recordkeeping for dairy taxes and lenders is the place to start.
Explaining milk price risk in plain words
Most lenders know that milk prices are volatile. What they want to hear is which part of the risk you cannot change, which part you can, and what you have done about each.
Start with what the system does. Federal order prices set minimum prices handlers pay; they do not guarantee your farm a profit. Farm Credit East puts it this way: producers cannot change marketing-order prices, but they can manage milk quality, components and a risk management plan. That sentence is a good outline for your answer.
Then walk through a stress test with made-up round numbers. Suppose your break-even is a certain price per hundredweight, and ask what happens to the account if the milk price falls by a few dollars for six months. Show the month the balance goes negative and what you would do: draw on a reserve, trim feed costs, delay a purchase. A lender who sees a tested plan is looking at a different risk than one who sees none.
If you use margin tools, describe them honestly. Payments from Dairy Margin Coverage or Dairy Revenue Protection depend on prices and are not guaranteed income, so they belong in the plan as a cushion, not a line of revenue. Point to the dairy margin coverage overview and the details from FSA if the lender asks how it works.
Questions to ask in return
A loan conversation goes both ways. Ask:
- What debt service coverage and working capital measures does the lender use for dairies?
- How does the lender treat cooperative equity and deferred payments? Unpaid equity is generally not cash for debt service.
- How are operating lines structured to cover the months between milk checks? Milk is paid monthly with a mid-month advance, so payroll and feed come due between payments.
- What triggers a covenant review, and what warning would you get?
Tone matters. Offering bad news early, such as a soft quarter or a heifer-cost problem, with a plan attached reads as management. Bad news discovered later reads as risk.
Know your alternatives
FSA lists direct and guaranteed operating and ownership loans, and its guaranteed program works through commercial lenders. The FSA operating loan page lists current limits and repayment terms, which change, so check it rather than quoting figures from memory. Your local FSA office or extension farm business specialist can review your plan before you meet a lender. Use the dairy farm loan repayment scenario to test a payment against several margin cases first.
This is general education, not financial advice. Your lender and accountant know your situation.
Keep reading
- Dairy Cash Flow Scenario Planner
- Dairy Cash Reserve Planner
- Dairy Farm Budget Forecast Exercise
- Monthly Milk Revenue Budget
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: FSA Farm Operating Loans · IRS Publication 583, Starting a Business and Keeping Records · Farm Credit East, understanding your milk check
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.