Milk Check Monthly Audit
Most farms check the total at the foot of the milk check and little else. The cost of that habit is quiet. A wrong weight, a miscoded test or a deduction that crept up two cents can run for a year before anyone looks. A thirty minute audit each month, done the same way every time, is the cheapest insurance a dairy has.
Gather three things before you start
Keep these together in one folder, paper or digital: the milk statement, your own records of shipments (tank pickup slips or the farm's own tank readings), and the published prices for the month. The USDA AMS site posts the Announcement of Class and Component Prices, and your order's market administrator posts the PPD. Wisconsin Extension recommends reading a check in a fixed order, so the routine below follows it.
The six-step routine
- Pounds. Add your pickup slips and compare with the total on the statement. Note any day that differs. A mismatch of even one load is worth a call.
- Components. Compare butterfat, protein and other solids percentages against what you usually see and against any independent test. A sudden jump or drop with no change in the herd or ration is a signal to ask about sampling and lab results.
- Component pounds. Multiply pounds of milk by each percentage to confirm the component pounds shown.
- Prices. Check that the announced component prices and the PPD on the statement match the published figures for that month and your order. Prices are posted by AMS and the market administrator, so a mismatch is quick to confirm.
- Premiums and quality. Check each premium against your buyer's schedule. For somatic cell count, see the somatic cell count premium tracking guide.
- Deductions. Convert each to dollars per hundredweight and compare with last month, as in milk check premiums and deductions.
A worked example with made-up numbers
Suppose a farm's slips total 1,200,000 pounds for the month, but the statement shows 1,188,000. The gap is 12,000 pounds, which is 120 hundredweight. Even at a modest value per hundredweight, that is a meaningful amount of money, and it is also a sign that a load was missed, double-counted or recorded in the wrong month. The audit found it in step one, before any math on prices was needed.
Now suppose hauling shows $9,000 on 11,880 hundredweight. Divide: that is about 76 cents per hundredweight. Last month it was 70 cents on the same volume. Six cents is small on one check but is a pattern to watch. Farm Credit East's method, mailbox price as total premium and component dollars minus all deductions, divided by pounds and multiplied by 100, gives you one comparable figure each month.
Record the result
Use a simple log: month, pounds, component test, announced prices, premiums, deductions per cwt, mailbox price, and a note. Over a year the log shows seasonal patterns, such as lower component tests in summer heat, and supports any conversation with your buyer or lender. If something does not match, write it down with the date before you call, and use the milk check reconciliation worksheet to document the correction.
What to do when something looks off
Call your field representative or plant first, with the page and line in front of you. Ask for the source of the number: the scale ticket, the lab report or the schedule. Most differences are timing or coding. If a buyer cannot explain a change, ask for the policy in writing. If it affects a regulated price, such as a wrong announced figure, the market administrator for your order can verify the published numbers. Keep the paper trail. For a longer explanation of why a check changes from one month to the next, read why your milk check changed this month.
Keep reading
- Milk Check Reconciliation Worksheet
- Dairy Farmer Milk Check Terms Glossary
- Milk Hauling Deduction Worksheet
- Milk Marketing Fee Tracker
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: UW Extension, Reading the Milk Check · Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check · USDA AMS, Announcement of Class and Component Prices
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.