Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Monthly Milk Revenue Budget

Annual budgets are easy to write and easy to ignore. A monthly milk revenue budget is different: every time a check arrives, it gets a grade. Within a few months you learn whether your assumptions were realistic, and where the surprises usually come from.

Build the budget from the check's own parts

Use the same structure as the milk statement, so budget and actual can be compared line by line. UW-Madison Extension groups statement items into physical shipment data, component-based value, pooling adjustments such as the producer price differential, and deductions. Copy that layout.

For each month, enter an expected value for:

  1. Pounds shipped. Cows milking, pounds per cow per day, days in the month. Use your own history for the same month last year, adjusted for herd changes.
  2. Component tests. Butterfat, protein and other solids percentages, and somatic cell count. Components often move with season, so last year's same month is a better guide than the annual average.
  3. Component value. Pounds of each component times the unit price for that month. You cannot know the price in advance. State the price you assumed and its source. Do not present a forecast as a fact.
  4. PPD and premiums. Use a conservative estimate, since the PPD can be negative. UW describes a negative PPD as an accounting outcome of pooling, not a check error.
  5. Deductions. Hauling, check-off, cooperative fees and any retains, from your last several statements.

A short example with made-up numbers

Suppose the budget for one month assumes 240,000 pounds shipped (2,400 cwt) and a net mailbox price of $19.50 per cwt. Budgeted revenue: 2,400 x $19.50 = $46,800.

The actual check shows 232,000 pounds (2,320 cwt) and a net price of $20.10, giving $46,632. The revenue is very close to budget, and that could lead you to move on. Do not. Price was $0.60 above plan, worth about $1,392 on actual volume, and volume was 80 cwt below plan, costing about $1,560 at the budgeted price. Two errors canceled out. Next month they may not.

This is why each month needs a variance line for volume and a variance line for price. The farm milk revenue and volume dashboard shows how to display it.

Updating with actuals

After each check, do four things in ten minutes.

  • Enter actual pounds, tests, gross, deductions and net.
  • Compute the mailbox price. Farm Credit East's method is total premium and component dollars minus all deductions, divided by total pounds, times 100.
  • Write the variance for volume and price, with a one-line reason.
  • Re-forecast the remaining months. If volume has run below plan for three months, the problem is probably the plan, not bad luck.

Check that announced prices on the statement match the published monthly announcements. Farm Credit East says prices on the check should match the monthly Pool Price Announcement, and our milk check monthly audit lays out how to confirm that. If something is off, ask your handler.

Handle the advance and the timing

If your buyer pays a mid-month advance, Penn State Extension describes it as a partial payment, not a cost. Track it as cash timing, and keep it out of the mailbox price calculation. Then the budget can feed straight into your cash flow scenario planner, which needs to know when the money lands.

Seasonality and the traps in it

  • Spring flush tends to bring more milk and, per Farm Credit East, higher balancing deductions, so do not copy a fall deduction into May.
  • Fresh cow groups, heat stress and ration changes show up as changes in pounds and components.
  • Premium programs and base plans, where a buyer has them, may change terms with little notice. Read your handler's current schedule instead of relying on old ones.

When to bring in others

If your actual net price keeps coming in under plan while announced prices behave as expected, the gap sits in deductions, premiums or the PPD. Call your cooperative field representative or handler and ask for an explanation line by line. If the issue persists, an extension dairy specialist or farm business adviser can look at your statements with you. The state directory at state directory can help you find your regulator, extension dairy specialist or order administrator. For the farm-wide picture, tie this budget into your dairy farm budget forecast exercise.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: UW-Madison Extension, Reading the Milk Check · Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check · Penn State Extension, Understanding Your Milk Check

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.