Dairy Milk Production Versus Revenue Log
Pounds are up 6 percent and the deposit is barely higher. That mismatch is the single most useful clue a milk-check log can give you, and you will only see it if you write the two numbers down side by side every month.
Set up the log
One row per month. Keep it simple enough that you will still be doing it in two years.
- Pounds shipped and cwt (divide by 100).
- Total milk revenue, after deductions if you want the mailbox view, or gross if you track deductions separately.
- Revenue per cwt, which is revenue divided by cwt.
- Average cows, and pounds per cow per day.
- Butterfat, protein and somatic cell count from the statement.
- A note column: weather, ration change, new group, hauler change, anything unusual.
UW Extension recommends reading a check in sequence, starting with total pounds shipped and component tests before checking prices, PPD, premiums and deductions. The log follows that order. See its milk check walkthrough for the line items.
A two-month example with invented numbers
- Month 1: 300,000 pounds, which is 3,000 cwt, and revenue $66,000. Revenue per cwt is $22.00.
- Month 2: 318,000 pounds, which is 3,180 cwt, and revenue $66,780. Revenue per cwt is $21.00.
Pounds rose 6 percent. Revenue rose about 1.2 percent. Revenue per cwt fell $1.00. Something other than volume is going on, and the log tells you to look.
Reading a divergence
When pounds and revenue move in different directions, check the likely suspects in this order.
- Component tests. Did butterfat or protein fall? Heat, ration changes, early lactation and cow health all shift tests. More milk with lower tests can bring less money.
- Quality. A rise in somatic cell count can reduce premiums or increase deductions, and Penn State Extension notes that high SCC can alter the components that milk checks pay on.
- Class and component prices. Announced prices change every month, and the whole order moves together.
- PPD. A swing in the producer price differential can raise or lower revenue per cwt even when your cows did not change.
- Deductions. Cooperatives may charge balancing or other fees that rise when milk is abundant. Farm Credit East notes balancing deductions tend to be higher in spring and early summer and lower in fall.
- Timing. A mid-month advance, a corrected statement or a payment delayed over month-end can shift revenue between months.
Work through why your milk check changed this month if the cause is not obvious. If you suspect a deduction is wrong, a dispute log is the right place to start.
Patterns that show up over a year
Pounds typically follow a seasonal curve that depends on calving pattern and weather, while revenue per cwt follows markets, components and deductions. Plot both lines. When they track together, volume is driving the check. When they separate, price or components are. After two or three years the log tells you which months are normally tight, which is the information you need for your seasonal production planning and cash flow.
Add a second row for the same month last year. A year-over-year comparison removes most of the seasonal noise.
When to pick up the phone
Call your handler or cooperative field rep when revenue per cwt falls and you cannot find a cause in tests, prices or deductions on the statement. Bring the log and the last three checks. Ask for the pooling, premium and deduction schedules in writing. A tidy log turns a vague complaint into a specific question, and specific questions get answered.
Keep reading
- Farm-Level Revenue Sensitivity Analysis
- Farm Milk Revenue and Volume Dashboard
- Benchmarking Your Dairy Against Others
- Labor, Land and Overhead in Dairy Cost Accounting
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: UW Extension, Reading the Milk Check · Penn State Extension, Effects of a High Somatic Cell Count · Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.