Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Why Your Milk Check Changed This Month

The deposit is $11,000 lower than last month and the herd seems fine. Before blaming the buyer, the market or the weather, work through the possible causes in order. A milk check is a sum of several moving parts, and each one has a typical fingerprint.

Step one: split the change into price and quantity

Divide the net check by cwt shipped to get dollars per cwt, then compare both numbers with last month. If pounds fell 8 percent and the per-cwt price barely moved, you have a volume story: fewer days in the month, fresh cow timing, heat stress, a group dried off, or a missed pickup. If pounds held steady and the per-cwt number moved, move on to the next steps.

Calendar effects fool people. February is short; a 31-day month has about 10 percent more pickup days than a 28-day one. Also check whether an advance or a prior-month adjustment is hiding in the net.

Step two: your components

Under multiple component pricing, UW-Madison Extension says producers with different component tests get different checks, and component differences are the most common reason neighbors' prices differ. Recompute butterfat, protein and other solids pounds from your tests. A butterfat test that slid 0.15 points after a ration change or a hot spell is worth real money on a million pounds. Your nutritionist can help interpret component shifts.

Step three: announced prices and class mix

Component prices move monthly. USDA publishes them in the announcement of class and component prices, and the prices on your statement should match that publication. The class and component prices apply to the preceding month. If your unit price differs from the announcement, ask your handler why.

Do not expect a headline price to equal your check. A farm's price is the sum of components, PPD, premiums and deductions, and the mailbox price differs from the headline for that reason.

Step four: the PPD

When component values move sharply, the PPD often moves in the opposite direction. UW says a negative PPD is an accounting outcome of pooling, not a check error, and that conditions producing one include rapidly rising manufacturing prices, high Class III relative to the blend, falling Class I utilization and depooling. Look at the PPD line on its own. A $1.00 per cwt swing in PPD on 10,000 cwt (made-up numbers) is $10,000, which could explain the whole drop. The PPD guide and the pooling and depooling explainer cover why.

Step five: premiums

Quality premiums, volume premiums and "market" premiums change by schedule. A cell count that crossed a tier, a lower volume bracket, or a buyer's decision to change a premium can all appear here. Ask for the current schedule in writing.

Step six: deductions and timing

Divide hauling, promotion, marketing and cooperative lines by cwt and compare with prior months. Farm Credit East notes cooperative balancing charges tend to run higher in spring and early summer. Also check for a catch-up from an earlier error, a payment schedule that moved, or a retain.

A quick symptom table, in words

  • Pounds down, price per cwt flat: volume event.
  • Pounds flat, butterfat or protein pounds down: component event.
  • Components fine, PPD lower: pooling event.
  • Components and PPD fine, net lower: premiums or deductions.
  • One new line: ask what it is, who set it and when it started.

Keep a one-line note every month for the cause. In a year, you will see your own seasonal pattern. The monthly milk check audit formalizes this routine, and the line-by-line reading guide shows each line with an example. When the arithmetic is done and the number still stings, farm.FM offers dairy and farm humor as a free side dish.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: UW-Madison Extension, Reading the Milk Check · USDA AMS, Announcement of Class and Component Prices · Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.