Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Income and Expense Comparison

Two farms each spend $240,000 on feed. One is thriving and the other is not. A raw dollar comparison cannot tell you which is which, and neither can a comparison of this year with last year if the herd grew in between. Fair comparison needs a common yardstick.

Normalize before you compare

Convert every line to a per-unit figure. The two standard units are per hundredweight shipped and per cow.

Here is a made-up example. Year A: 24,000 cwt shipped, feed cost $215,000. Year B: 27,000 cwt shipped, feed cost $240,000. Total feed is up about 11.6 percent. But feed per cwt went from about $8.96 to about $8.89, so feed became slightly more efficient, even as the dollar total rose.

Do the same for revenue, labor, replacements and interest. When a line grows faster than your milk volume, that line deserves a look. When it grows slower, find out why, because that is where the gains are.

If you are not sure how to calculate per-cwt figures, dairy production cost per hundredweight explains the arithmetic.

Traps that make comparisons unfair

  • Cash timing. Most farms use cash accounting, which the IRS says in Publication 225 is the method most farmers use because it is easier. Under it, prepaid feed, a delayed check or thirteen milk payments in one tax year can distort a year. Compare multi-year averages or adjust for timing before drawing conclusions. Read the IRS Publication 225 and ask your tax professional how your records are treated.
  • Price level. A year with higher feed prices will look worse on a dollar basis even if you managed well. Compare against price indices or against peers in the same year.
  • Herd and inventory changes. Buying or selling cattle, or raising more heifers than usual, shifts costs and income. Separate livestock sales and purchases so they do not hide the operating result.
  • One-offs. Insurance recoveries, a large equipment repair or asset sales belong on their own line, flagged.
  • Definitions. If one source includes family labor and another does not, the totals cannot be compared.

Benchmark against others, carefully

Outside comparisons are useful when they match your size, region and system. Two public sources are worth knowing. USDA's Economic Research Service provides milk cost of production estimates that vary by state and by size of operation, and FINBIN at the University of Minnesota offers summary and benchmark reports, including dairy costs and returns by herd size. Neither tells you what your costs should be. Both give a reasonable range to check against.

When you find a gap, ask why before assuming you are wrong. A farm that pays more for labor may also ship more milk per cow. A farm with higher feed per cwt may be buying forage because it has little land. The guide on benchmarking your dairy against others goes deeper into choosing a peer group.

A comparison routine you can repeat

  1. Pull three years of income and expense, using the same categories.
  2. Convert each line to per cwt and per cow.
  3. Mark one-time items and adjust.
  4. Highlight lines that moved more than 10 percent per cwt in either direction.
  5. For each highlighted line, write one sentence explaining it. If you cannot, investigate.

Put the result next to the previous version of your enterprise budget so you can see whether the plan matched what happened.

If you are unsure where to find a farm business analysis program, a benchmark group or an extension dairy specialist, the state directory is a good starting point. Many states have programs that will compare your numbers against similar farms confidentially.

A fair comparison is rarely flattering to every line, but it is useful to all of them. Done once a year, it becomes the best habit on the farm.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA ERS, Milk Cost of Production Estimates · FINBIN, University of Minnesota · IRS, Publication 225 Farmer's Tax Guide

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.