Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Forward Contracting Your Milk: A Cautious Guide

The sales pitch is easy to remember: lock in a price and sleep at night. The harder part is what the contract does not lock in, and what happens to a farmer who has fixed a price just before the market rallies. Forward contracting is a legitimate tool, and it rewards a farm that understands exactly what it is selling.

What forward pricing is

A forward contract fixes a price now for milk to be shipped later. It can come from a cooperative or a handler, or it can be built with CME Class III or Class IV futures. Texas A&M Extension explains that a futures contract has no milk delivery at expiration; it settles against the announced Class III or IV price, and hedgers who sell milk sell futures. Penn State Extension adds that cooperatives often forward contract milk for members, may take a small fee from the price, and sometimes offer a basis contract that protects the whole milk check rather than only the Class III value.

Federal rules sit behind the handler contracts. The Dairy Forward Pricing Program in 7 CFR Part 1145 lets handlers forward contract Class II, III or IV milk free of order minimum price obligations on that milk, with voluntary contracts and a disclosure statement. Wisconsin Extension notes the authority has lapsed and been renewed repeatedly, so ask your handler about current status and check the eCFR.

The benefit, and the catch

The benefit is certainty: a known price on part of your milk makes budgets, loan payments and feed purchases easier to plan. The catches are real:

  • Opportunity cost. If the market rises, the fixed portion misses the gain.
  • Basis. Penn State describes basis as the usual gap between your milk check and the announced Class III price. A contract at Class III leaves the producer carrying the producer price differential and any premiums or deductions, as the understanding basis in dairy markets article explains.
  • Volume risk. A herd that ships less than contracted still has the obligation.
  • Counterparty risk. Ask who pays if the other side fails.
  • Cash needs. A futures hedge can need margin deposits when the market moves against it; a handler contract usually does not. Ask which applies.

A made-up example

Illustrative round numbers only. A farm ships 200,000 pounds a month, which is 2,000 hundredweight. It fixes a price on 500 cwt, a quarter of its milk. If the market lands above the fixed price, the farm gets the fixed price on 500 cwt and the market price on 1,500 cwt. If the market lands below, the 500 cwt is protected and the rest takes the drop. The farm is never fully protected, and never fully exposed. A small portion over a short horizon is a cautious way to start.

A cautious routine

  1. Know your cost per hundredweight from your own books before talking to anyone.
  2. Decide the share of milk you can fix without sleepless nights, and write it down.
  3. Ask the buyer in writing: what is fixed, which months, what fees, what basis.
  4. Compare the result with the protection you could get from DMC or DRP in the risk plan guide; these programs work differently and can complement a contract.
  5. Log the decision and the reasoning in a dairy risk management decision journal so that you can learn from it later.

What to ask before signing

How is the fixed price defined? Is it the gross or the mailbox price? What happens if I cannot ship the volume? Who can see my account? Can I exit early, and what does it cost? For futures and options, talk to a licensed broker; for the contract language, an attorney and your lender. This guide explains the concepts and gives no advice on what or when to trade.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: Penn State Extension, Using Milk Futures to Lock in Profitability · UW Extension, The Dairy Forward Pricing Program · Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, Dairy Futures and Options

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.