Dairy Risk Management Decision Journal
Ask a dairy farmer in February why he bought coverage last September and the answer is often "it seemed like the right thing." That is a fair answer on the day and a useless one a year later. A decision journal fixes that. It is a plain record of what you chose, what you knew and why, written when you decide and reread when the results come in.
Why farms with good instincts still need one
Risk decisions are judged by outcomes, and outcomes are noisy. A put option that expires worthless was not a mistake if the price rose and your milk check benefited. A skipped enrollment looks smart in a good year and foolish in a bad one. Without a record, memory rewrites the story to match the result. With a record, you can ask the useful question: was the reasoning sound given what was known?
A journal also helps outside the barn. IRS Publication 225 says records support items reported on returns and help when working with a bank or creditors. A lender who sees a dated rationale for each risk decision sees a manager with a method.
What to write on the day you decide
Keep each entry short, a half page at most. Capture these items:
- Date and decision. For example: enrolled in Dairy Margin Coverage at a chosen level, bought a Dairy Revenue Protection endorsement, signed a forward contract, bought a put, or deliberately did nothing. Doing nothing is a decision and belongs in the journal.
- What it covers. Pounds or cwt, months, which price series or index. Write the unit.
- What it costs. Premium, administrative fee, commissions, margin deposits. Use figures from the agent or FSA office, not estimates.
- Why. Which cell in your margin grid does this protect? What number are you trying to defend, such as break-even or debt service?
- What you believed. Your view of milk and feed, written in one sentence, labeled as opinion.
- What would change your mind. An exit rule or a trigger date.
- Who you consulted. FSA office, crop insurance agent, broker, lender, co-op.
- Source links. Where the program rules came from, such as the FSA page or RMA fact sheet.
Worked entry in made-up numbers
"Mar 3. Bought one Dairy-RP quarterly endorsement for the third quarter on 5,000 cwt of declared milk, 85 percent coverage, class pricing. Cost quoted by agent: written down. Why: our cash margin falls below debt service if revenue drops more than about 10 percent. Belief: feed looks manageable, milk price uncertain, opinion only. Exit: none planned, ask agent what can be changed after purchase. Talked to: agent, lender."
The example uses invented numbers and a hypothetical choice. Real endorsements, sales periods and subsidies come from RMA's Dairy Revenue Protection fact sheet, and DMC rules are on FSA's DMC page.
The review routine
Set two review dates when you make each entry: one at the end of the coverage period and one a quarter later.
- Did the tool pay, and did the payment match the pain? Compare it with your own milk check and feed bills.
- Was the cost what you expected? Note surprises in fees or margin calls.
- Was your belief right? Score the reasoning separately from the result.
- Would you make the same decision with the same information? If yes, the outcome was luck. If no, write what you will change.
Fold the findings into your annual review and update the risk management plan. If you are weighing programs, the DMC versus DRP comparison gives you better inputs for item 4. For retaining the paperwork itself, see financial record retention.
Habits that keep it alive
Use whatever you will actually open: a notebook in the milk house, a spreadsheet, a shared doc with your spouse or partner. Write the entry the same day. Keep it honest, including the entries you would rather forget. Journals do not predict markets, and they are not tax, legal or investment advice. They make your next decision better than your last one, and when the books are closed and the worry is parked, farm.FM is a fine place for a laugh about farm life.
Keep reading
- Cooperative Milk Marketing Agreement Guide
- Milk Marketing Contract Checklist
- Dairy Supply Contracts Research
- Dairy Cooperative Patronage Research
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: IRS Publication 225, Farmer's Tax Guide · RMA, Dairy Revenue Protection Fact Sheet · FSA, Dairy Margin Coverage Program
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.