Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Options Research Worksheet

A put option is the closest thing in dairy risk management to buying an umbrella: you pay a known amount up front, and if it never rains you lose only that amount. The research work is deciding what umbrella you need, how much it costs and whether it actually covers your check. This walk-through shows the reasoning in the order a careful farm business adviser would use.

Start with the words

  • Put: the right to sell a futures contract at a set price. A put sets a floor, which is why milk producers focus on them. UW Extension says buying a put sets a floor, the buyer's maximum loss is the premium, and the buyer faces no margin call risk.
  • Call: the right to buy at a set price. In dairy, calls show up mainly on the feed side, such as the call-like part of LGM-Dairy, which RMA likens to buying a call option on feed costs and a put option on milk prices.
  • Strike price: the price written into the option. CME's fact card lists strike intervals such as $0.25 for Class III milk and cheese and $0.02 for butter and nonfat dry milk.
  • Premium: the price you pay for the option. CME's introduction says premiums are negotiated on Globex and quoted as a single price that splits into intrinsic value and time value.
  • Intrinsic value: a call has it when the strike is below the futures price; a put has it when the strike is above. Time value is whatever is left of the premium, and it shrinks as expiry approaches.

CME also describes these options as American style, meaning they can be exercised before expiration.

Reading a quote

Write down, for any quote you research: the contract (Class III, Class IV and so on), the month, the type (put or call), the strike, the premium and the futures price at the same moment. Check units with the price unit guide, because premiums on class contracts are in dollars per cwt. Never pull a premium from one day and a futures price from another.

A worked floor price in invented numbers

Suppose the Class III futures price for a future month is $18.50 per cwt. You are researching a put with an $18.00 strike and a premium of $0.60 per cwt. One contract covers 2,000 cwt.

  1. Cost: $0.60 times 2,000 cwt is $1,200 before commissions and fees.
  2. Effective floor: strike minus premium is $17.40 per cwt on the covered milk, judged against the Class III price, not your check.
  3. If the price settles at $16.00: the put is worth $2.00 per cwt, or $4,000, so net of the premium the position earns $2,800.
  4. If the price settles at $21.00: the put expires with no value. You lose the $1,200 and keep the benefit of the higher milk price.

Every number here is made up to show the logic. It is not a quote or forecast.

Questions the worksheet should force you to answer

  • How much milk am I covering? If you ship 400,000 pounds a month, that is 4,000 cwt, so one contract covers half.
  • What price does my check track? Options pay on the contract's settlement, not on your check. Your order, premiums and deductions create a gap, discussed in CME futures for beginners.
  • What is my break-even? Compare the floor with your cost per cwt from margin planning. A floor far below break-even protects little.
  • How does this compare with insurance? RMA's Dairy Revenue Protection and FSA's Dairy Margin Coverage cover similar risks with different costs and rules. UW Extension's compatibility table lists which can be combined.
  • What will I do if I am wrong? Write the exit rule before buying.

Last steps before calling

Run three or four quotes, strikes above and below the futures price, and compare cost per dollar of protection. Put your reasoning in the decision journal, then call a licensed broker with the quotes and your questions. Ask for all fees in writing. A broker explains markets and executes orders, but the decision, and the research behind it, are yours. Talk with your lender and accountant too, since option costs and gains affect cash flow and taxes in ways this article cannot assess.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: CME Group, Introduction to Dairy Futures and Options · CME Group, Dairy Futures and Options Fact Card · UW Extension, Dairy Price Risk Management Tools · RMA, LGM-Dairy Fact Sheet

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.