Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Cooperative Milk Marketing Agreement Guide

The agreement usually gets signed once, at the kitchen table, when a farm is changing buyers or a young producer is shipping a first load. Then it sits in a drawer for ten years while the milk check arrives every month and nobody remembers what the paper actually promised. When the hauler changes, the plant closes or a neighbor gets a better deal, that paper suddenly matters a great deal.

What the agreement is actually promising

A marketing agreement is a contract between you and a handler, which can be a cooperative or a proprietary plant. It does not set the federal order minimum price. USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service explains that order provisions apply to handlers, and that a handler pays at least the order minimum for pooled milk. Everything above or below that floor, meaning premiums, hauling, fees and retains, is a matter between you and your buyer, and the agreement is where it lives.

Read it for three kinds of promise. First, what the buyer commits to: to pick up all your milk, to pay by a certain date, to pay at least the order's minimum uniform price. Second, what you commit to: to ship all of your milk to this buyer, to meet quality standards, to give notice before leaving. Third, what is left to the buyer's discretion, such as "the board may establish deductions from time to time." That third category deserves the most attention.

Cooperative membership versus a plain handler contract

A cooperative adds a second relationship on top of the sales contract: you are an owner. AMS reviews and qualifies milk marketing cooperatives each year, and the list is posted on its cooperative qualification page. Ownership brings a vote, a share of the earnings and also obligations: dues, possibly balancing charges, and equity that may be withheld from your check. Farm Credit East notes that cooperative members typically see membership dues and sometimes balancing fees, and that balancing deductions tend to run higher in the spring flush than in the fall.

A proprietary handler usually offers no ownership, but may offer a simpler price: orders minimum plus a premium schedule. Neither is automatically better. Compare the whole check, not the headline premium. The guide on why your mailbox price differs from the headline price shows how to do that comparison.

Terms that decide how much freedom you have

Go through the agreement with a highlighter and mark each of these:

  • Term and renewal. Does it end on a date, or renew itself every year unless you object? Many farms stay bound simply because nobody noticed the renewal window.
  • Notice to leave. How many days or months of written notice, to whom, and by what method? Some agreements only open an exit at a particular time of year.
  • Exit costs. Is there a penalty, a forfeited premium or a delay in paying out your equity when you leave?
  • Exclusive supply. Does it require all milk, or only a stated volume?
  • Pricing language. Is the premium written in the agreement, or published in a separate schedule the buyer can change? Ask for the current schedule in writing.
  • Hauling and stop charges. The Wisconsin Extension milk hauling quick reference points out that hauling charges are negotiated among farms, haulers and handlers, not regulated by the orders, so the agreement or its schedule is the only protection you have.

Questions to put to the field representative

Written answers beat verbal ones. Ask what happens to your equity if you retire, sell the herd or switch buyers, and over what period it is paid back. Ask whether the plant has to take your milk during a surplus, and what happens to your check if it does not. Ask who pays when a load is rejected for quality. Ask how past deduction changes were communicated.

Then test the answers against your own numbers. Pull the last twelve statements and run them through the milk check monthly audit, so that you know your true net price before comparing any offer. The milk marketing contract checklist gives a longer list of clauses if you are comparing two written offers.

When to bring in outside help

An agreement that binds you for years, ties up large equity or limits your ability to sell the farm is worth a conversation with your attorney and your lender before signing, because both will care how the milk market is secured. Your lender may also want a copy for the loan file. This guide explains the concepts; it is not legal advice, and the exact meaning of any clause depends on your state and on your signed document.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA AMS, Milk Marketing Cooperative Associations · Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check · UW Extension, Milk Hauling Quick Reference

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.