Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Supply Contracts Research

A supply contract looks simple from a distance: the buyer wants a steady milk supply, the farm wants a steady price. Up close it has moving parts that a student project or a farm business plan should pull apart one at a time. This guide gives a research method, so the work ends with a clear picture instead of a pile of brochures.

Step one: define the price being fixed

Many contracts do not fix the whole milk check. Penn State Extension notes that a producer's basis is the usual gap between the milk check and the announced Class III price, reflecting component values, marketing premiums and federal order benefits. A contract tied to the Class III price still leaves the farm exposed to that gap. The Wisconsin Extension article on the Dairy Forward Pricing Program makes the same point: a contract priced at Class III leaves the producer carrying the producer price differential between the blend price and Class III.

So the first research question is always "what exactly is fixed?" Write the answer in one sentence: a Class III price, a Class IV price, a component price, or the whole mailbox price. If it is not the whole check, list what stays floating. The producer price differential guide explains the biggest floater.

Step two: find who offers what

Gather offers from every buyer who can reach your farm: cooperative, proprietary plant and any broker or marketing service. For each, record in one row:

  • What is being fixed and for which months
  • Fees or a small cut taken from the price (Penn State says cooperatives may take a small fee from the futures price when forward contracting for members)
  • Whether the contract is a basis contract covering the whole check
  • Term, renewal and exit terms
  • Whether your milk volume is a promise or an estimate

Keep this as a spreadsheet; a student can score each offer on clarity, flexibility and cost.

Step three: understand the rules behind forward contracts

Federal rules matter here. Under 7 CFR Part 1145, the Dairy Forward Pricing Program lets handlers forward contract Class II, III or IV milk free of federal order minimum price obligations for that milk. Contracts must be voluntary and carry a disclosure statement. Wisconsin Extension reports the authority has repeatedly lapsed and been renewed, so the status on the day you sign must be checked in the eCFR and with your handler. This guide does not state the current status, because it can change.

Step four: test against a made-up scenario

Illustrative numbers only. Suppose a farm ships 100,000 pounds a month, which is 1,000 hundredweight. Suppose a contract fixes a price on half that volume, and the price the market later announces comes in lower than the fixed price. The farm gains on 500 cwt and gets the market on the rest. If the market comes in higher, the farm gives up the extra on 500 cwt. Run both directions on paper. A farm that only studies the good direction has not done the research.

Add the cash-flow side: a fixed price does not shield the farm from the quality and hauling deductions on the check, so subtract those before calling the result a margin. The milk price volatility planning guide shows how to build that range.

Step five: ask the buyer these questions

  1. What happens if my herd ships less than the contracted volume?
  2. What happens if the buyer cannot take my milk?
  3. Is any premium guaranteed for the full term, or can it be changed?
  4. Who is the counterparty, and what protects my payment?
  5. How do I get out, and what does that cost?

Record the answers with the date and the person's name. Compare them with the checklist in the milk marketing contract checklist. For a project, finish with a one page summary that states the recommendation and its biggest risk. Contract terms vary widely, and a lender, attorney or licensed broker should review a real contract before signing.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: UW Extension, The Dairy Forward Pricing Program · Penn State Extension, Using Milk Futures to Lock in Profitability · eCFR, 7 CFR Part 1145

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.