Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Why Your Mailbox Price Differs From the Headline Price

Every month somebody posts the Class III price on the feed store bulletin board, and every month a dairy farmer looks at his own check and wonders where the money went. The headline price is real. It is just not the price you are paid. Between the number on the news and the number in your account sit several layers, some set by rule, some by your buyer, and some by you.

Start with what the headline actually is

The headline is usually a Class price from the USDA AMS monthly announcement. Under the Federal order rules, USDA sets minimum formula prices that handlers must pay. UW-Madison Extension puts it plainly: orders generate minimum formula prices, they do not set the producer pay price. Class III in particular is a formula built from the cheese and whey surveys, with make allowances and yield factors, expressed per hundredweight at 3.5 percent butterfat. It describes one use of milk, at a standard test, in the abstract.

Your milk is something else. It has its own pounds, its own butterfat, protein and other solids, a somatic cell count, a hauling route and a buyer with its own rules. The class price comparison shows how different the classes are before your farm enters the picture.

The layers, in the order they hit

Walk down a check and you meet these steps.

  1. Component values. In an order that uses multiple component pricing, you are paid on pounds of butterfat, protein and other solids at the announced component prices. A farm with rich tests is paid for more components per cwt than the 3.5 percent standard.
  2. Producer price differential. The PPD pulls the pooled value of all classes back to a uniform price. It can be positive or negative, and it depends on how the market administrator's pool works out for the month. The PPD guide explains the mechanics.
  3. Premiums. Volume, quality and market premiums come from your handler or cooperative, not from the order. AMS notes in its California handout that premiums above order minimums are not enforced by the order.
  4. Quality adjustments. Somatic cell adjustments and plant quality incentives raise or lower the price.
  5. Deductions. Hauling, check-off, cooperative fees and equity retains reduce the check.

Penn State Extension defines the mailbox milk price as the gross price less marketing deductions such as advertising, hauling and cooperative fees, and notes it excludes advances, forward contracts and assignments. Farm Credit East gives the arithmetic: total dollars after deductions, divided by total pounds, times 100.

Why your neighbor's number differs from yours

UW-Madison Extension lists the common reasons two neighboring farms get different mailbox prices. The most frequent is different component tests. After that come handler depooling decisions, different premium schedules, different deductions or contract terms, and sitting in different Federal orders.

The difference between the announced price and what the farmer actually receives has a name: basis. A trade article in Progressive Dairy described a private analyst's peer group where basis shrank over several years, mostly through deductions and premium changes, and treated it as a dated example rather than an official statistic. The point for you is that basis is not fixed. It drifts, and the drift is visible only if you track it.

How to measure your own gap

Pull your last three statements and build a simple sheet.

  • Column one: the announced blend or uniform price for your order in that month, taken from the market administrator or AMS.
  • Column two: your mailbox price, calculated by the Farm Credit East method.
  • Column three: column one minus column two, which is your basis for the month.

Then break the gap into pieces. Divide each deduction by cwt shipped. Compare your tests with the order average. Note whether the PPD you were paid matches the announced PPD. If it does not, ask your handler why, in writing.

A scenario that catches people: the PPD is negative, the Class III headline is high, and the farm feels cheated. The statement may be correct. Under the rules, a negative PPD can reflect depooling or a strong manufacturing class price relative to the pool, and your handler cannot change it. What your handler can explain are the premiums and deductions on your own check, and those are worth a conversation. The month-to-month check change guide is a good companion.

What you can and cannot move

You cannot change an announced price. Farm Credit East says as much: producers cannot change marketing order prices but can manage milk quality, components and a risk plan. You can change your tests, cell count, hauling arrangement and, over time, your buyer or co-op terms.

For the rules behind the layers, read the AMS price formula page and the UW-Madison check walkthrough. Then put your own basis on paper.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: UW-Madison Extension, Reading the Milk Check · Penn State Extension, Understanding Your Milk Check · Farm Credit East, Understanding Your Milk Check · USDA AMS Price Formulas

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.