Milk Component Yield and Revenue Exercise
Two neighbors ship to the same plant in the same month. One has bigger cows. The other has richer milk. At the end of the month the checks are closer than anyone expected, and the farmer with the lower volume is still smiling. The arithmetic below shows why.
The setup
All numbers are invented for practice. They are not market prices and not any real farm. We will assume a component-priced order where the producer is paid on pounds of butterfat, protein and other solids, and we will ignore premiums, deductions and the producer price differential to keep the focus on yield.
Made-up component prices per pound:
- Butterfat: $2.00
- Protein: $3.00
- Other solids: $0.50
Three farms, same month:
- Farm A: 100,000 pounds of milk, tests 3.6 percent fat, 3.1 percent protein, 5.7 percent other solids.
- Farm B: 100,000 pounds of milk, tests 4.0 percent fat, 3.3 percent protein, 5.8 percent other solids.
- Farm C: 110,000 pounds of milk, tests 3.5 percent fat, 3.0 percent protein, 5.7 percent other solids.
Step one: dollars per cwt
For each farm, multiply each test by its price. A test of 3.6 percent means 3.6 pounds of fat per 100 pounds of milk, so you can multiply the test number directly by the per-pound price to get dollars per cwt.
Farm A: 3.6 x $2.00 = $7.20; 3.1 x $3.00 = $9.30; 5.7 x $0.50 = $2.85. Total $19.35 per cwt.
Farm B: 4.0 x $2.00 = $8.00; 3.3 x $3.00 = $9.90; 5.8 x $0.50 = $2.90. Total $20.80 per cwt.
Farm C: 3.5 x $2.00 = $7.00; 3.0 x $3.00 = $9.00; 5.7 x $0.50 = $2.85. Total $18.85 per cwt.
Step two: revenue for the month
Convert pounds to cwt (divide by 100), then multiply. If the conversion is rusty, use the milk pounds to hundredweight calculator.
- Farm A: 1,000 cwt x $19.35 = $19,350.
- Farm B: 1,000 cwt x $20.80 = $20,800.
- Farm C: 1,100 cwt x $18.85 = $20,735.
Farm C ships 10 percent more milk than Farm B and earns $65 less. Farm B has $1.45 more per cwt than Farm A, or $1,450 on 1,000 cwt.
What the exercise shows
- Tests matter on every pound. Each 0.1 point of fat test is worth 10 cents per cwt at $2.00 per pound of fat. Protein is worth 30 cents per cwt per 0.1 point at the made-up $3.00 price.
- Volume is not free. More milk usually means more feed, labor, hauling and handling. Farm C's extra 10,000 pounds had to cost less than $65 of net revenue gain, which is almost never true, so Farm B is clearly ahead once costs are counted. Compare with income over feed cost.
- Prices change the answer. If protein fell and fat rose, the ranking of the three farms could shift. Rerun the sheet with your own prices from the monthly announcement, using the butterfat and protein tracking routines.
Try variations
Change one thing at a time:
- Raise Farm A's fat test to 3.8 percent and see the change in dollars per cwt.
- Cut Farm B's volume by 5 percent and see what test improvement offsets it.
- Switch to a skim-fat order, where the check uses a uniform skim price and a butterfat price instead of separate protein and other solids values, as UW Extension explains. The same farms would be ranked differently.
What real checks add
Real statements add premiums, hauling, check-off assessments and deductions, plus the PPD. The University of Wisconsin Extension milk check walkthrough lists these. USDA ERS notes that Jersey and crossbred cows have gained popularity because their milk tends to carry higher shares of fat and solids than Holstein milk, a point on the ERS dairy background page. Whether that pays for a particular herd depends on feed, facilities and the order.
For the full pricing logic, read understanding milk component pricing. Students can turn this exercise into a 4-H poster by adding a fourth farm that they design themselves.
Keep reading
- Dairy Product Price Survey Explained
- USDA NASS All Milk Price Guide
- Understanding the USDA AMS Announced Prices
- What Is a Hundredweight of Milk and Why Does It Matter
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: UW Extension milk check walkthrough · USDA ERS Dairy Background
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.