Dairy Processor Price versus Farm Milk Price
A family at the grocery store sees a gallon of milk and a block of cheese, does the math in its head, and decides dairy farmers must be getting rich. A farmer looking at the milk check sees a different story. Both are looking at real prices. They are prices for different things, at different points in the chain, set by different forces.
Three different prices
It helps to name them separately.
- Retail price. What a shopper pays for a finished product. It covers the plant, packaging, trucking, the store's costs and its profit, along with the milk itself.
- Processor price. What a plant receives when it sells bulk cheese, butter, powder or whey, or what it pays to buy raw milk. The weekly commodity prices AMS collects from manufacturers are processor-level prices.
- Farm price. What lands on your milk statement per hundredweight after the order's minimum, premiums, hauling and deductions.
AMS says the federal order program does three things: it sets minimum uniform prices, ensures proper payments through auditing and component testing, and provides market information. In its overview booklet for the order system, AMS also stresses that order provisions apply to handlers, not to dairy farmers. The order does not reach out and regulate the retail shelf. It sets a floor for what handlers owe for raw milk.
How a shelf price turns into a farm price, and where it does not
The link between plant prices and your check is a formula, not a negotiation. The weekly sales prices of butter, cheddar blocks, nonfat dry milk and dry whey feed the component prices, which feed the class prices. The formulas subtract make allowances, which are USDA's allowance for what it costs a plant to turn milk into each product. That is why a commodity price and a farm price are never the same number. You can read the published formulas in 7 CFR 1000.50.
The retail price is not an input to those formulas. A store can raise a price without changing your check, and the reverse also happens. Retail is shaped by competition among stores, promotions, packaging, energy and labor, and the cost of bringing a product to a shopper. Farm milk is a raw ingredient.
A made-up example of the gap
Suppose, with round numbers invented for practice, a gallon of milk sells for a dollar figure well above its raw milk cost. At roughly 8.6 pounds per gallon, the milk in that jug is about 0.086 cwt. If the farm earned, say, $20 per cwt, the farm's share of that gallon would be about $1.72. Everything else on the receipt covers other costs and margins. Do not quote that as a real farm share. Actual shares vary by product, region and year. The unit math is in the milk pounds to hundredweight calculator.
Where to find numbers for each link
- Processor-level data: the weekly National Dairy Products Sales Report and the monthly price announcements, explained in understanding the USDA AMS announced prices.
- Farm-level data: AMS federal order statistics include class and component prices by order, uniform prices and mailbox milk prices, plus retail milk prices, on the marketing order statistics page. Putting those series side by side is the cleanest way to see the spread for your own order.
- Your own check: your statement is the only farm price that matters to your bank balance, and the next section shows why it differs from the announced numbers.
Why your check is not the order minimum either
Even the farm-level numbers are not your price. Neighbors can receive different mailbox prices because of component tests, premium schedules, deductions, contract terms and pooling decisions, which why your mailbox price differs from the headline price covers in detail. The order sets a minimum that handlers must pay; your cooperative or plant may pay more through premiums or less through deductions.
What to do with the difference
Resist the urge to measure fairness by the retail spread. Use it as a reminder that most of the dollars between farm and fork pay for work farms do not do. Spend your effort on what you can move: components, quality, hauling terms and your plan for price swings. Then compare your result to peers using class prices compared so you know which announced number your check actually tracks.
Keep reading
- Dairy Processing Demand and Farm Prices
- Butterfat Price Tracking Worksheet
- Protein Price Tracking Worksheet
- Other Solids Price Tracking Worksheet
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: USDA AMS Dairy Federal Milk Marketing Order booklet · USDA AMS Federal Milk Marketing Order statistics · eCFR 7 CFR 1000.50
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.