Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Dairy Processing Demand and Farm Prices

Picture a cheese plant that suddenly needs more milk because its customers want more pizza cheese. The plant buys, sells more blocks, and the price on blocks changes. A few weeks later that change reaches farm checks. Nobody called the farm. The signal traveled through a survey and a formula.

The chain, link by link

  1. Consumers and food companies buy products. Demand for cheese, butter, powder and whey shows up as plant sales.
  2. Plants report those sales. Manufacturers of butter, cheddar, nonfat dry milk and dry whey report weekly sales to USDA, as described in the dairy product price survey explained.
  3. AMS averages the prices. The weekly figures are weighted by pounds sold.
  4. Formulas convert product prices to component prices. Butter becomes the butterfat price, cheese becomes protein, whey becomes other solids, and nonfat dry milk becomes nonfat solids.
  5. Component prices become class prices and your check. Class III reflects cheese and whey. Class IV reflects butter and powder. Class I and II have their own links.

The formulas are published in 7 CFR 1000.50, and AMS prints the same formulas on each month's class and component price announcement.

Why plant demand is blunted before it reaches you

Make allowances. The formulas subtract a per-pound amount for the cost of making each product. A plant's profits and losses stay with the plant; the formula passes through only the change in product price, net of that fixed deduction. See understanding make allowances.

Yield factors. The formulas turn product prices into milk component values using fixed conversion factors, not each plant's actual yield.

Averaging. Prices are weighted averages over four or five weeks for the final monthly announcement, and over two weeks for the advanced Class I and II factors. A sudden jump in demand is spread out. That is also why a farm can see the news in the headlines weeks before the check moves.

Pooling. In a federal order, the check reflects a market-wide blend, not the class of the plant that happened to take your load. That is the job of the producer price differential, covered in the dairy producer price differential guide.

Which plants matter where you ship

Your own region shapes how much of this you feel directly. Where cheese plants dominate, strong cheese demand tends to show up in components. Where more milk goes to bottling, Class I carries more weight. In every order, though, the commodity prices are national averages. Your neighbor's plant could be running below capacity while the national price rises, and the formula still pays the national number.

Seasonal demand

University of Wisconsin Extension has written about seasonal demand patterns in dairy, with U.S. domestic disappearance of butter and American cheese showing seasonal peaks in the fall and a dip after the holidays, as discussed in its seasonal spending article. Do not assume the past repeats every year, but it is a reason to keep a calendar of your own checks and compare each month to the same month last year.

Reading demand without trading on it

You do not have to predict plant demand to use the idea. Three habits are enough:

  • Watch the weekly product price series on AMS dairy graphs and note which direction butter, cheese, powder and whey are moving.
  • Match that to which class your handler's milk mostly serves, using the order's utilization data.
  • Compare the movement to the next two checks, so you learn the lag for your own order.

A decision about forward pricing or insurance should go through your co-op, a broker or an agent, not through a blog post. For the policy side of that choice, start with Dairy Revenue Protection or Class III milk prices.

A question to ask your field rep

"Which products does our plant mostly make, and how much of our milk is pooled versus handled outside the order?" The answer tells you which demand signals matter most to your price, and which are filtered by someone else's contract.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA AMS Announcement of Class and Component Prices · eCFR 7 CFR 1000.50 · UW Extension seasonal spending article

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.