Class Prices Compared: Which One Moves Your Check
Ask five dairy farmers which class price matters most and you may hear five answers. A Wisconsin producer says Class III. A Florida producer says Class I. A farmer shipping to a butter and powder plant watches Class IV. They are all partly right, and the reason is that no single class price is "your" price. Your check is built from the pooled value of all classes, shaped by your handler and your order.
What each class prices
Under 7 CFR 1000.40, milk is classified by how the handler uses it.
- Class I: milk in fluid beverage products.
- Class II: soft products such as cottage cheese, yogurt, ice cream mixes, sour cream and cream products, per the eCFR and AMS plain-language summaries.
- Class III: hard cheeses, cream cheese and other spreadable cheeses.
- Class IV: butter and any milk product in dried form, including nonfat dry milk.
The formulas differ. Class III skim is built from protein and other solids prices, which come from the cheese and dry whey surveys. Class IV skim is built from the nonfat solids price, which comes from nonfat dry milk. Butterfat comes from the butter survey and feeds every class. Class II skim is the advanced Class IV skim price plus 70 cents, and Class I uses the higher of the advanced Class III or Class IV skim factors plus a location differential. The Class III and Class IV guides go into the arithmetic.
Why the pool blurs the answer
In a Federal order, handlers pay according to what they do with the milk, but producers are paid from a pool. UW-Madison Extension describes pooling as a pool of dollars, not a pool of milk: the market administrator divides total pooled value by total pooled pounds to get the uniform price. A handler whose class obligations exceed the blend pays into the pool; one below it draws out.
So a farm shipping to a cheese plant does not receive "Class III." It receives the order's blend, built from every class in the pool, plus premiums and less deductions. What the Class III price does is move the blend, and move the producer price differential, depending on how much milk is in cheese.
Which class tends to matter to whom
This depends on your order and your handler, and nobody can answer it for you from a distance. Some patterns to test against your own statement:
- Fluid-heavy orders and regions. Where much of the milk goes to beverage use, Class I carries more weight in the pool, and location differentials in 7 CFR 1000.52 differ by county. Check the table for your county.
- Cheese-heavy orders. Class III moves the blend more, and cheese and whey markets matter more to your outcome.
- Butter and powder regions. Class IV and the butterfat price matter more.
- Cooperative members. The co-op may blend returns across plants, so your check may reflect all of its uses, not a single class.
Ask your handler or field representative what share of the milk goes to each use, and what the plant that receives your milk makes. That one answer tells you more than any chart.
A routine for finding your own driver
- Pull the monthly AMS announcement and note Class II, III and IV prices and the component prices.
- Pull your order's uniform price and PPD from the market administrator's page.
- Lay six months of both beside your mailbox price, from your statement.
- Mark months where Class III and Class IV moved apart and see whether your check followed the blend or the class.
- Note the months you had a negative PPD and compare with Class III strength.
You will usually find your price follows the blend with a lag, plus your components. A farm with high protein will respond more to the protein price. The component pricing guide explains why.
Depooling can complicate the picture. Class II, III and IV milk can be kept out of the pool under order rules, a decision made by handlers each month, which is why a high manufacturing price does not always show up in your blend. The pooling and depooling guide covers it.
Read the formulas in 7 CFR 1000.50 and the class definitions in 7 CFR 1000.40, and compare with the UW-Madison check walkthrough.
Keep reading
- Class I Fluid Milk Pricing Explained
- Class II Milk Price Guide
- Understanding Class III Milk Prices
- Understanding Class IV Milk Prices
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: eCFR 7 CFR 1000.40 · eCFR 7 CFR 1000.50 · UW-Madison Extension, Reading the Milk Check · USDA AMS Federal Order Booklet
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.