Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Milk Check Premiums and Deductions

Two neighbors ship the same number of pounds on the same day and their checks end up different. The reason is almost never a mistake. It is the premium and deduction lines, which vary by buyer far more than the federal order prices do. Knowing each line is how a farm learns what its milk is really worth.

Where premiums and deductions sit

Wisconsin Extension groups milk check items into four categories: physical shipment data, component-based value, pooling adjustments such as the producer price differential, and deductions. Premiums come between the pooling line and the deductions. Cornell's Mark Stephenson, in an exhibit filed with USDA AMS, defines the net marketing value as the PPD plus total premiums minus total deductions, which is a useful way to think about it.

The order sets minimum prices. Wisconsin Extension notes that premiums, quality adjustments, hauling, check-off assessments and cooperative adjustments come on top of the pool value. Plants and cooperatives use different schedules.

Premium lines you may see

The Cornell exhibit sorts premiums into volume, quality and market premiums, and notes that market premiums have gone by many names: cooperative, base, competitive, supply, special, market adjustment and pooling premium. Read the buyer's own definitions. Typical lines include:

  • Volume premium. Paid for larger pickups or higher daily volume.
  • Quality premium. Often tied to somatic cell count and bacteria counts. Penn State Extension says thresholds and amounts are handler specific, and gives a dated example from the Mideast order where a premium applied below a set SCC and a deduction above it; do not treat it as a current rule. See the milk quality premium record.
  • Component or butterfat adjustments. Some buyers add their own on top of the order.
  • Market or competitive premium. Intended to hold a milk supply; may change at short notice.

Deduction lines you may see

  • Hauling. Negotiated, not regulated by the orders. Wisconsin Extension's hauling reference gives the rule of thumb of about a cent per hundredweight per mile and shows charges fall as farm size rises, partly because many handlers charge flat fees.
  • Promotion and check-off. Dairy promotion assessments, local and national.
  • Cooperative dues, balancing and marketing fees. Farm Credit East says balancing deductions tend to be higher in spring and early summer when milk is plentiful.
  • Equity retains. Money withheld on your behalf; see the dairy cooperative patronage research guide.
  • Advances. Penn State says a mid-month advance is a partial payment, not a cost, so do not count it as a deduction.

Turn every line into per-hundredweight

Penn State notes that deductions often appear as a lump sum, but you can compute a per-unit cost by dividing by the hundredweight shipped. Do this for each line each month: line dollars divided by cwt shipped. Put the results in one row. Over a year, patterns show up that a single check hides, such as the spring balancing swing.

Penn State also defines the mailbox price as gross price less marketing deductions such as advertising, hauling and cooperative fees. Whatever your buyer prints, compute your own using the reading your milk statement line by line method and keep a log such as the milk marketing fee tracker.

Why they vary, and what to ask

Buyers compete for milk with premiums and recover costs with deductions. A high premium can come with high hauling or a retain. So compare net, not gross. When a line is new or changed, ask your field representative or plant what it is called, what it covers, how it is calculated and where the policy is written. Any answer you cannot get in writing is worth following up. If the explanation does not match the check, keep a note and see the dairy marketing deduction dispute log.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: UW Extension, Reading the Milk Check · Penn State Extension, Understanding Your Milk Check · UW Extension, Milk Hauling Quick Reference

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.