Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Milk Price Seasonality Investigation

Every dairy farmer has heard that milk is cheapest in spring and dearer in fall. Fewer have checked it against the data, and the ones who do often find the pattern is real in volume, shaky in price, and easy to overstate. This is a method for running your own investigation with free public numbers.

Start with volume, where the pattern is firmest

Cow biology gives seasonality its best evidence. A Penn State study led by Salfer and Harvatine analyzed national milk composition from 2000 to 2015 along with 1,684 cows in 11 Pennsylvania herds. It found that milk yield, fat and protein follow annual biological rhythms more than heat and humidity do. On average yield peaked in April, fat and protein yield in February, fat concentration in January and protein concentration in December, with lows in summer. The swings were larger in northern herds and shrank with distance south.

Your own pull: download monthly milk per cow for your state from the NASS Milk Production report, which also lists cow numbers. Put twelve months in a row, then repeat for several earlier years. If your state's peak does not match the national story, that is a finding, not an error.

Then test price

Price seasonality is a weaker signal because many forces overlap. Wisconsin extension notes that domestic use of butter and American cheese peaks in fall with a post-holiday dip, and links holiday demand to fall price strength. That is a demand-side pattern layered on a supply-side one.

A workable test:

  1. Pull monthly class and component prices from the AMS price announcements, and the NASS All Milk price if you want a broader number. See the announced prices guide for what each series is.
  2. For each year, rank the twelve months from lowest to highest price.
  3. Count how often a given month lands in the bottom three or top three.
  4. If a month is bottom-three in six of ten years, the pattern deserves a note. If it is four of ten, it is closer to noise.

AMS also posts monthly graphs of milk production, cheese and butter production and cold storage, which let you compare product flow against price on one screen.

Pitfalls that fool smart people

  • Trend hiding as season. Cow numbers and prices drift up or down over several years. Compare each month with the same month a year earlier, or with that year's own average, rather than raw month to month.
  • One strange year. A single disrupted year can create a fake seasonal peak. Use as many years as you can and look at each separately.
  • Revisions. NASS revises production estimates the following month, and again each February, so early figures are not final. Note the vintage of every number.
  • Mixing price definitions. A class price, a blend price and your mailbox price do not share a seasonal pattern, because premiums, deductions and the PPD have their own rhythms. Read how the uniform price works before comparing.

From finding to farm decision

Seasonality matters on a farm when it touches cash and herd management. If your data shows weaker prices in the months your herd ships the most milk, your revenue is concentrated in softer months, which belongs in your seasonal production planning. Ask your handler whether it pays seasonal incentives or runs base programs; those are plant policies and vary, so get them in writing.

Keep a simple log with the table of ranks, the data source and download date, and one sentence on what surprised you. A 4-H or FFA member can turn exactly this into a project with a chart and a conclusion, and a producer can use it to sanity check any sales pitch that begins with "prices always rise in the fall."

When the spreadsheet work is done and the chart finally behaves, farm.FM is a fine place to go for some farm humor.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: Penn State News: annual biological rhythms in milk production · UW Extension: seasonal spending and the dairy sector · USDA AMS Dairy Graphs

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.