Federal Order Referendums: How Producers Vote
Most dairy farmers never see a ballot for a federal order referendum. Then one year a thick envelope arrives, the return deadline is a few weeks away, and the question on it will shape the minimum prices that every handler in your order must pay for years. Knowing how the vote works before the envelope shows up is worth an afternoon.
Where the vote sits in the amendment process
Federal order changes are industry driven. AMS describes the process as having proposals, a public hearing, a recommended decision, a comment period, a final decision, a producer referendum and finally a final rule. The vote comes late, after USDA has already written its final decision, and it is a yes or no on the amended order as a whole.
That last point trips people up. Producers vote on the entire order, not on individual provisions, according to the AMS referendum handout. You cannot approve the new make allowances and reject the Class I differential changes. If an order fails to get the needed approval, USDA would move toward terminating that order, which is why the stakes are bigger than a normal ballot measure.
Who is eligible and what counts as approval
For the 2024-25 referenda on the national pricing amendments, AMS says eligible voters were producers whose milk was pooled on a federal order in the representative month, which was January 2024. Eligibility is tied to a specific month, so a farm that started shipping later, or whose milk was not pooled that month, would not have received a ballot.
Approval needs at least two-thirds of the producers voting, or producers who supplied at least two-thirds of the milk volume represented in the vote. Either test can carry the order. AMS reports that producers in each of the 11 orders approved the 2025 amendments.
Some practical rules from the handout: ballots may not be emailed or faxed, and unsigned or photocopied ballots are disqualified. For the 2024-25 round, mail ballots had to be postmarked by December 31, 2024 and received by January 15, 2025. Treat those as examples of how strict the process is, and read the dates on whatever ballot you actually receive.
Cooperative bloc voting
Many farmers belong to a cooperative, and a cooperative that is qualified to bloc vote can cast a single ballot on behalf of its eligible members. CRS notes that changing this would take an act of Congress. Members of cooperatives that elect not to bloc vote receive their own ballots.
This means two things for a member. First, your co-op board and management usually decide how the bloc vote is cast, so the place to influence the outcome is the annual meeting, the delegate process and member surveys, not the mailbox. Second, you may still get nothing in the mail and that can be normal. If you are unsure which situation you are in, call the co-op field staff and ask directly whether they bloc vote and how they decide.
Independent farmers shipping to a proprietary handler vote individually, so the paper ballot matters more for them.
A short routine when a referendum is announced
- Find the final decision and read the summary, not just the news coverage. The Federal Register notice guide explains how to decode one.
- Work out which of the changes touch your milk. For the 2025 round, how the 2025 changes reach your check walks through that.
- Ask your co-op or handler whether it bloc votes and what position it is taking, and why.
- Confirm your eligibility month with your market administrator. AMS lists each order's administrator, and your state directory can point you to your regional contacts.
- If you receive a ballot, sign it, mail it early, and keep a copy of your own notes on why you voted as you did.
Common mistakes
- Assuming a silent mailbox means you lost your vote. Check whether your co-op votes in bloc.
- Treating the referendum as a vote on one favorite or hated provision.
- Waiting until the postmark deadline. Mail delays happen.
- Confusing the order referendum with Dairy Margin Coverage enrollment, which is run by FSA and is a separate program. For how pooled prices behave after the vote, see how pooling and depooling work.
Results are announced in the Federal Register as a final rule or a termination of proceeding, per the AMS handout. If you want to know what a given order covers and how it was built, the federal order basics guide is the place to start.
Keep reading
- How to Read a Federal Register Notice About Dairy
- Dairy and the Farm Bill: What to Watch
- How 2025 Federal Order Changes Reach Your Milk Check
- Federal Milk Marketing Order Basics
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: AMS Dairy FMMO Referendum Handout · AMS National FMMO Pricing Hearing FAQ and Final Decision · CRS, Federal Milk Marketing Orders
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.