Dairy Policy Public Comment Research Guide
A public comment is the cheapest way a dairy farmer can put a fact into a federal record. During the national order proceeding, 128 comments came in on the recommended decision, and the final decision changed from it in several ways. That is a small pile of paper with real consequences, and a short, specific comment from a farm can sit comfortably in it.
Finding what is open
AMS posts rulemaking notices on its proposed rules page, and dairy marketing order items appear there. AMS describes its rulemaking in four steps: initial planning, a proposed rule, public comments and a final rule. The final rule summarizes and responds to the comments received.
Each notice carries a comment deadline. For the national order decision, the recommended decision was published in the Federal Register on July 15, 2024 with a 60-day comment period that ended September 13, 2024. Deadlines like that are firm, so put the closing date on your calendar the day you find the notice. The pace of the whole process is in the hearing overview.
Follow the docket number. The national hearing used AMS-DA-23-0031, and AMS links the public docket from its proceeding page. Comments are normally submitted through the instructions in the notice, in a section usually called ADDRESSES, so follow those exactly. Federal Register and regulations.gov pages should be checked directly on those sites for the current submission steps.
Reading before you write
Read the notice from the top. The summary tells you what is proposed, the dates section gives deadlines, and the supplementary information explains why. The guide on how to read a Federal Register notice about dairy goes section by section. Then read the proposed regulatory text, because the preamble can be more cautious than the rule itself.
Ask three questions:
- Which orders and which classes does this touch?
- Does it change a formula, a date, a definition or a procedure?
- What would it do to a check like mine?
For the third, rebuild your own numbers. Pull a recent statement, find your components, and use the formulas in 7 CFR 1000.50 to test a change with round numbers. If you can say "on 100,000 pounds a month, this would change my check by about this much," label it as your estimate and show the arithmetic.
What makes a comment useful
This part is practice, not an agency rule, but it matches how a final rule works: the agency responds to substance.
- Address the specific proposal by name or section.
- Say who you are in business terms: herd size, order, buyer type, how long you have shipped.
- Give one concrete effect with numbers from your records, not general anger.
- State what you want, whether to adopt, reject or modify.
- Keep it short and keep personal data out. Comments are public, so leave out account numbers and anything private.
A form letter circulated by an organization is allowed, but a comment in your own words about your own farm adds something a copy does not. If your cooperative is submitting comments, ask how it gathered member input and whether it reflects herds like yours. You can still comment separately.
After you submit
Save a copy and note the date. When the final rule arrives, look for the section where USDA responds to comments and check whether your point was addressed. Results of producer votes are announced in the Federal Register as a final rule or a termination of the proceeding, as the AMS referendum handout explains. For the vote itself, read how producers vote in referendums, and for the content of recent changes see federal order reform research.
Keep reading
- Dairy Margin Coverage Overview
- Dairy Revenue Protection Overview
- How Federal Order Pooling and Depooling Work
- Federal Order Referendums: How Producers Vote
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: USDA AMS Proposed Rules · USDA AMS Rulemaking · USDA AMS National FMMO Pricing Hearing · USDA AMS FMMO Referendum Handout
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.