Milk Price And Dairy Policy

Milk Price Charts Data Quality Checklist

A chart can be built from perfectly accurate numbers and still leave a false impression. Dairy prices swing, so there is plenty of room for a chart to flatter a sales pitch, a marketing plan or an argument. Run each chart you rely on past the checks below.

The axis and the frame

Does the vertical axis start at zero? For a line chart of prices, a truncated axis is often fine and even useful, but it makes small moves look huge. Read the axis labels first and ask how many dollars a gridline represents. For bar charts, a truncated axis is usually misleading, because bar length is supposed to mean size.

Is there a second axis? Dual-axis charts pairing milk price with feed cost or cow numbers can be made to cross wherever the designer likes. Prefer two panels sharing a time axis.

What dates are shown? A window that begins at a low point and ends at a high point sells a trend. Ask what the same chart looks like with a longer window and ask which months were left out.

The data behind the line

What is the unit? Class prices are dollars per hundredweight at 3.5 percent butterfat. Component and product prices are per pound. A line that mixes them without conversion is wrong; see Milk Price per Pound and per Cwt Conversion.

Which series? The USDA all-milk price reported by NASS is stated before deduction for hauling and includes premiums, so it is not the same as the announced Class III price or your mailbox price. A chart title like "Farm milk price" does not say which one it is.

Is it final or first release? NDPSR weekly prices can be revised for four weeks, while the monthly announcements are not revised. NASS production figures are revised the following month. A chart pulled on different days can show slightly different history. Good charts say "as of" and cite the source.

Is the line smoothed? A 12-month moving average hides seasonal dips and spikes that matter for cash flow. A chart labeled "trend" may be a smoothed curve, so check the legend for the window.

Example: one chart, told two ways (made-up numbers)

Imagine monthly Class III prices that rise for three months, fall for six, then recover. Chart A, showing only the three-month rise on an axis from $16 to $18, looks like a boom. Chart B, showing 24 months on an axis starting at zero, looks like a gentle wobble. Both come from the same table. The farm decision, for example how much of next year's milk to protect, should not depend on which chart landed in your inbox. For that, look at Milk Price Volatility Planning Guide.

A quick scoring routine

  1. Source named, with a link? If not, find it or discard the chart.
  2. Unit and class written on the axis?
  3. Start and end dates stated, with a window long enough to include a full cycle?
  4. Smoothing or indexing disclosed?
  5. Revisions or "as first released" disclosed?
  6. Could a different axis or window flip the message?

Three or more "no" answers means treat the chart as an illustration, not evidence.

Making your own charts

Build charts from the raw table, show the unit in the title, use the same axis for years you compare, and keep seasonal patterns visible. The AMS posts its own dairy graphs for CME cheese, butter, dry whey and nonfat dry milk, and the numbers behind them can be checked against the AMS class price announcement. When a chart is part of a news story, pair this list with How to Verify a Dairy Price News Story and, for the fiscal side of a decision, Dairy Break Even Price Worksheet.

Keep reading

Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.

Sources: USDA AMS Dairy Graphs · USDA AMS Announcement of Class and Component Prices · USDA NASS Agricultural Prices report

General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.