Butter Price Report Research Log
Butter is the commodity that sets the butterfat price on every milk check, so a farmer who ignores butter reports is ignoring a piece of income in every class. The trouble is that "the butter price" is at least three different numbers. A log that records the source and the definition next to each entry saves you from comparing apples to cheese.
Know which butter number you are logging
Three series get called "the butter price."
- CME spot butter. AMS Dairy Market News reprints CME cash market closing prices daily. This is a spot market, published at 12:15 p.m. Central according to the AMS release-times table, with weekly graphs on Fridays.
- Regional DMN butter reports. Central, Northeast and West bulk butter reports describe trading in each region. AMS lists them separately from the national highlights.
- NDPSR butter. The National Dairy Products Sales Report is the mandatory survey of AA butter sales, and it is the one that feeds the formulas. It covers salted butter at 80 percent butterfat in 25-kilogram and 68-pound boxes meeting USDA Grade AA.
For anything that touches your milk check, the NDPSR number is the one that counts. The CME spot price is a signal, not the formula input. AMS describes the spot market as separate from the survey, and the commodity source comparison goes deeper.
What the log should capture
Make a simple sheet, one row per observation, with these columns:
- Date you looked and date the report covers.
- Source name and report title.
- Price per pound and the unit, with pounds sold when the report states it.
- Whether the figure is preliminary or revised. NDPSR figures can be revised for the previous four weeks after first release, and revised numbers are marked with an asterisk.
- A one-line note in your own words on what moved and why you think so.
Write the definition once at the top of the sheet: butter surveyed is AA, salted, 80 percent butterfat. Add a column for the monthly figure used in the AMS class announcement, because that average is what actually feeds your butterfat price.
From butter to butterfat
The eCFR formula says butterfat price equals the U.S. average AMS AA butter price less 22.72 cents, multiplied by 1.211. The 22.72 cents is the butter make allowance under the 2025 amendments, and 1.211 is the pounds of butter per pound of butterfat, as AMS worksheets describe. Those constants changed in 2025, so a log that reaches back before June 2025 should note the formula era. AMS's price-formulas page separates calculations through May 2025 from those after.
A worked method with made-up numbers: suppose the monthly butter average were $2.00 per pound (illustrative only). Subtract 22.72 cents to get $1.7728, multiply by 1.211, and you have a butterfat price near $2.15 per pound. Each extra 10 cents on butter moves the butterfat price by about 12 cents. Your butterfat tracking worksheet can carry this forward month by month.
Reading movements without fooling yourself
- Check timing. The advanced Class I butterfat factor uses two weeks of NDPSR data, while the monthly announcement uses four or five weeks, per AMS. A fast move shows up in the advanced price first.
- Check inventories. NASS Cold Storage reports butter stocks, and Dairy Products reports production. Both help explain why prices moved. The dairy product stocks guide shows how.
- Check seasonality. UW-Madison Extension discusses seasonal demand patterns for butter and cheese, with peaks in the fall and a dip after the holidays.
- Do not forecast from one week. A log is a record, not a prediction. Write what happened and the source, and leave the forecasting to people paid to be wrong in public.
Keep the links to the AMS dairy market news page and the weekly sales report at the top of your sheet. A student who logs twelve months of butter this way has a better feel for butterfat income than most people who read headlines.
Keep reading
- Cheddar Cheese Price Report Research Log
- Nonfat Dry Milk Report Research Log
- Dry Whey Price Report Research Log
- Class Price Announcement Calendar
Find your state: see federal order, dairy regulator, extension, cooperative and youth dairy listings in the state directory.
Sources: USDA AMS Dairy Market News · AMS National Dairy Products Sales Report · eCFR 7 CFR 1000.50 · AMS Report Release Times
General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or investment advice. Prices, programs and rules change and differ by order, handler and state: confirm with USDA, your handler or cooperative, your lender and your extension dairy specialist.